Gzjkdkv 25/2 F@<H@I F?7HC79<KJ@97BI& @D9( 9EHFEH7J< 9E;< E= 9ED;K9J 7D; <J?@9I 7D; M?@IJB<8BEM<H FEB@9O @DJHE;K9J@ED KYZd ;`ca`cReV ;`UV `W ;`_UfTe R_U =eYZTd R_U NYZde]VS]`hVc G`]ZTj' cVWVccVU e` Rd eYV m;`UV'n Zd Z_eV_UVU e` ac`gZUV `fc Rdd`TZReVd' Rd UVWZ_VU SV]`h' hZeY R T]VRc f_UVcdeR_UZ_X `W eYV acZ_TZa]Vd `W SfdZ_Vdd T`_UfTe R_U VeYZTd eYRe RcV ViaVTeVU `W eYV^ R_U e` RZU eYV^ Z_ ^R\Z_X VeYZTR] R_U ]VXR] UVTZdZ`_d hYV_ T`_UfTeZ_X eYV T`^aR_jod SfdZ_Vdd R_U aVcW`c^Z_X URj(e`(URj UfeZVd) KYV deR_URcUd dVe W`ceY Z_ eYV ;`UV Raa]j e` fd R]]) =gVcj Rdd`TZReV `W eYV T`^aR_j ^fde RT\_`h]VUXV YZd `c YVc cVgZVh `W' R_U RXcVV^V_e e` T`^a]j hZeY' eYV ;`UV Rd R T`_UZeZ`_ `W YZd `c YVc cV]ReZ`_dYZa hZeY eYV T`^aR_j %dVV 8aaV_UZi 8 ReeRTYVU YVcVe`&) KYV eVc^ mRdd`TZReVn Rd fdVU eYc`fXY`fe eYV ;`UV ^VR_d %Z& VgVcj Wf]] R_U aRce(eZ^V V^a]`jVV `W eYV T`^aR_j R_U Zed dfSdZUZRcZVd' %ZZ& R]] ^V^SVcd `W eYV T`^aR_jod dV_Z`c ^R_RXV^V_e' Z_T]fUZ_X eYV T`^aR_jod ;YZVW =iVTfeZgV FWWZTVc R_U ;YZVW >Z_R_TZR] FWWZTVc' R_U %ZZZ& VgVcj ^V^SVc `W eYV T`^aR_jod 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd' VgV_ ZW dfTY ^V^SVc Zd _`e V^a]`jVU Sj eYV T`^aR_j) H<FEHJ@D> L@EB7J@EDI KD;<H J?< 9E;<4 7DJ@'H<J7B@7J@ED FB<;>< Ae Zd `fc cVda`_dZSZ]Zej e` T`_UfTe `fcdV]gVd Z_ R_ VeYZTR] SfdZ_Vdd ^R__Vc R_U R]d` e` V_dfcV eYRe `eYVcd U` eYV dR^V) AW R_j `_V `W fd gZ`]ReVd eYVdV deR_URcUd' YV `c dYV TR_ ViaVTe R UZdTZa]Z_Rcj cVda`_dV' fa e` R_U Z_T]fUZ_X eVc^Z_ReZ`_ `W R_j V^a]`j^V_e `c `eYVc cV]ReZ`_dYZa hZeY eYV T`^aR_j' R_U a`ddZS]j `eYVc ]VXR] RTeZ`_) AW j`f RcV RhRcV `W R_j ScVRTY `W eYV ;`UV' j`f RcV `S]ZXReVU e` cVa`ce gZ`]ReZ`_d e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc' e` R_j ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' `c e` eYV R_`_j^`fd @`e]Z_V eYRe eYV T`^aR_j YRd cVeRZ_VU e` cVTVZgV dfTY cVa`ced' Rd UVdTcZSVU Z_ ^`cV UVeRZ] SV]`h) KYc`fXY VdeRS]ZdYZ_X R T`_WZUV_eZR] R_U R_`_j^`fd `aeZ`_ e` RTTVae R_U ac`TVdd dfTY cVa`ced' hV V_dfcV eYRe eYV X``U WRZeY VWW`ced `W R]] `W fd e` T`^a]j hZeY eYV ;`UV RcV _`e f_UVc^Z_VU) KYV ;`UV T`_eRZ_d R T]VRc R_eZ(cVeR]ZReZ`_ a]VUXV' ^VR_Z_X eYRe ZW j`f Z_ X``U WRZeY cVa`ce R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV Sj eYV T`^aR_j' `c Zed RXV_ed RTeZ_X `_ SVYR]W `W eYV T`^aR_j' e` eYV @`e]Z_V' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_`eYVc ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' eYV T`^aR_j hZ]] f_UVceR\V e` ac`eVTe j`f Wc`^ SVZ_X WZcVU' UV^`eVU' cVacZ^R_UVU `c `eYVchZdV YRc^VU W`c cVa`ceZ_X eYV gZ`]ReZ`_' VgV_ ZW eYV gZ`]ReZ`_ Z_g`]gVd j`f' j`fc dfaVcgZd`c' `c dV_Z`c ^R_RXV^V_e `W eYV T`^aR_j) E`eV' Y`hVgVc' eYRe hYZ]V j`f hZ]] _`e SV UZdTZa]Z_VU W`c cVa`ceZ_X R gZ`]ReZ`_' j`f ^Rj SV dfS[VTe e` UZdTZa]Z_V hZeY cVdaVTe e` eYV f_UVc]jZ_X T`_UfTe `c gZ`]ReZ`_) P`f RcV V_eZe]VU e` ^R\V eYV cVa`ce `_ R T`_WZUV_eZR] R_U R_`_j^`fd SRdZd) K` eYV VieV_e R_ Z_gVdeZXReZ`_ ^fde SV Z_ZeZReVU' eYV T`^aR_j hZ]] \VVa T`_WZUV_eZR] R_j cVa`ce j`f ^R\V e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_`eYVc ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV e` eYV VieV_e cVbfZcVU Sj Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh) 9ECFBO@D> M@J? J?< 9E;< KYV f]eZ^ReV cVda`_dZSZ]Zej W`c ^RZ_eRZ_Z_X `fc ;`UV cVded hZeY VRTY `W fd) 8d Z_UZgZUfR]d `W aVcd`_R] Z_eVXcZej' hV TR_ U` _` ]Vdd eYR_ e` SVYRgV Z_ R hRj eYRe hZ]] T`_eZ_fV e` ScZ_X TcVUZe e` `fcdV]gVd R_U `fc T`^aR_j) 8aa]jZ_X eYVdV deR_URcUd e` `fc SfdZ_Vdd ]ZgVd Zd R_ VieV_dZ`_ `W eYV gR]fVd ,


 
Sj hYZTY hV RcV \_`h_ Rd Z_UZgZUfR]d R_U Sj hYZTY hV hR_e e` SV \_`h_ Rd R T`^aR_j) K` eYRe V_U' eYV T`^aR_j YRd ^RUV eYV ;`UV afS]ZT]j RgRZ]RS]V `_ Zed hVS dZeV) Ae Zd `fc cVda`_dZSZ]Zej e` T`_UfTe `fcdV]gVd Z_ R_ VeYZTR] SfdZ_Vdd ^R__Vc R_U R]d` e` V_dfcV eYRe `eYVcd U` eYV dR^V) AW R_j `_V `W fd gZ`]ReVd eYVdV deR_URcUd' YV `c dYV TR_ ViaVTe R UZdTZa]Z_Rcj cVda`_dV' fa e` R_U Z_T]fUZ_X eVc^Z_ReZ`_ `W R_j V^a]`j^V_e `c `eYVc cV]ReZ`_dYZa hZeY eYV T`^aR_j' R_U a`ddZS]j `eYVc ]VXR] RTeZ`_) NYZ]V Ze Zd Z^a`ddZS]V W`c eYZd ;`UV e` UVdTcZSV VgVcj dZefReZ`_ eYRe ^Rj RcZdV' eYV deR_URcUd Via]RZ_VU Z_ eYZd ;`UV RcV XfZUV]Z_Vd eYRe dY`f]U X`gVc_ `fc T`_UfTe Re R]] eZ^Vd) AW j`f RcV T`_Wc`_eVU hZeY dZefReZ`_d _`e T`gVcVU Sj eYZd ;`UV' `c YRgV bfVdeZ`_d cVXRcUZ_X eYV ^ReeVcd eYRe RcV RUUcVddVU Z_ eYV ;`UV' j`f RcV fcXVU e` T`_df]e hZeY eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc' R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' `c R_`eYVc ^V^SVc `W ^R_RXV^V_e) >fceYVc^`cV' eYV a`]ZTZVd dVe W`ceY Z_ eYZd ;`UV RcV Z_ RUUZeZ`_ e` `eYVc a`]ZTZVd `W eYV T`^aR_j eYRe Rdd`TZReVd ^fde T`^a]j hZeY) ;`aZVd `W eYVdV `eYVc a`]ZTZVd RcV RgRZ]RS]V Wc`^ eYV @f^R_ IVd`fcTVd <VaRce^V_e `c `_ eYV T`^aR_jod A_ecR_Ve) KYV ac`gZdZ`_d `W eYV ;`UV cVXRcUZ_X eYV RTeZ`_d eYV T`^aR_j hZ]] eR\V RcV XfZUV]Z_Vd hYZTY eYV T`^aR_j Z_eV_Ud e` W`]]`h) KYVcV ^Rj SV TZcTf^deR_TVd' Y`hVgVc' eYRe Z_ eYV T`^aR_jod [fUX^V_e cVbfZcV UZWWVcV_e ^VRdfcVd `c RTeZ`_d R_U Z_ dfTY TRdVd Ze ^Rj RTe RTT`cUZ_X]j hYZ]V deZ]] ReeV^aeZ_X e` Wf]WZ]] eYV acZ_TZa]Vd f_UVc]jZ_X eYZd ;`UV) A_ eYV TRdV `W R_j Z_T`_dZdeV_Tj SVehVV_ eYV ac`gZdZ`_d dVe `fe Z_ eYZd ;`UV R_U eYV cf]Vd T`_eRZ_VU Z_ R_j ^R_URe`cj eVie' ]Rhd `c Z_eVcacVeZgV TRdV ]Rh Raa]ZTRS]V e` eYV T`^aR_j R_U Zed Rdd`TZReVd' eYV ]ReeVc acVgRZ]) A_ _` Z_deR_TV dY`f]U eYZd ;`UV SV Z_eVcacVeVU Rd ^`UZWjZ_X' R^V_UZ_X `c `eYVchZdV TYR_XZ_X R_j ]VXR] eVie R_U cV]ReVU ]VXR] acVTVUV_ed eYRe Raa]j e` eYV T`^aR_j R_U Zed Rdd`TZReVd)


 
KRS]V `W ;`_eV_ed GRXV A) N@AJKC=9CFN=I GFCA;P ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))), 8) FS]ZXReZ`_ e` IVa`ce MZ`]ReZ`_d `c JfdaVTeVU MZ`]ReZ`_d )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))), 9) NYZde]VS]`hVc ;`^a]ZR_TV @`e]Z_V W`c ;`_WZUV_eZR] R_U 8_`_j^`fd IVa`ceZ_X )), ;) 8_eZ(IVeR]ZReZ`_ G]VUXV ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))- AA) ADGC=D=EK8KAFE F> K@= ;F<= )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))- AAA) ?=E=I8C I=HLAI=D=EKJ )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))/ AM) ;FE>CA;KJ F> AEK=I=JK )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))/ M) GIFK=;KAFE 8E< GIFG=I LJ= F> ;FDG8EP 8JJ=KJ )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))1 8) Gc`aVc LdV `W ;`^aR_j Gc`aVcej ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))1 9) ;`_WZUV_eZR] A_W`c^ReZ`_ )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))1 ;) 8TTfcReV IVT`cUd R_U IVa`ceZ_X )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))1 <) <`Tf^V_e IVeV_eZ`_ ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))3 =) ;`ca`cReV 8UgR_TVd )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))3 MA) >8AI <=8CAE? NAK@ ;LJKFD=IJ' JLGGCA=IJ' ;FDG=KAKFIJ' 8E< 8JJF;A8K=J )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))3 8) ?ZgZ_X ?ZWed )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))4 9) IVTVZgZ_X ?ZWed ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))4 ;) L_WRZc ;`^aVeZeZ`_ ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))4 <) 8_eZecfde ;`_TVc_d ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),+ =) L_WRZc GcRTeZTVd Z_ A_eVc_ReZ`_R] 9fdZ_Vdd ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),- MAA) ?FM=IED=EK I=C8KAFEJ )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),- 8) ?`gVc_^V_e Gc`TfcV^V_e R_U >f_UZ_X ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),- 9) GRj^V_ed e` FWWZTZR]d ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),- ;) G`]ZeZTR] ;`_ecZSfeZ`_d ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),. MAAA) ;FDGCA8E;= NAK@ C8NJ' ILC=J 8E< I=?LC8KAFEJ )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),. 8) A_dZUVc KcRUZ_X G`]ZTj)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),. 9) =bfR] =^a]`j^V_e Faa`cef_Zej )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),/ ;) JVifR] @RcRdd^V_e G`]ZTj)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),/ <) @VR]eY' JRWVej $ =_gZc`_^V_e CRhd ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),/ AO) HL=JKAFEJ LE<=I K@= ;F<= 8E< N8AM=I GIF;=<LI=J )))))))))))))))))))))))))))),/ O) >I=HL=EKCP 8JB=< HL=JKAFEJ %>8HoJ& I=?8I<AE? I=GFIKAE? MAFC8KAFEJ LE<=I K@= ;F<=' N@AJKC=9CFN=I GFCA;P 8E< @FKCAE= ))))))))))))))))))))))))),0 8GG=E<AO 8 8JJF;A8K=oJ 8?I==D=EK KF ;FDGCP )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 8(,


 
@( M?@IJB<8BEM<H FEB@9O 7( EQ[XVPcX^] c^ HT_^ac LX^[PcX^]b ^a Idb_TRcTS LX^[PcX^]b 8_j Rdd`TZReV `W eYV T`^aR_j YRgZ_X R_j Z_W`c^ReZ`_ `c \_`h]VUXV cVXRcUZ_X eYV ViZdeV_TV `W R_j gZ`]ReZ`_ `c dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV YRd R Ufej e` cVa`ce eYV gZ`]ReZ`_ `c dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ e` eYV NYZde]VS]`hVc @`e]Z_V %eYV T`_eRTe UVeRZ]d W`c hYZTY RcV SV]`h&' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc' `c R_j `eYVc ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) 8dd`TZReVd RcV R]d` V_T`fcRXVU e` cRZdV R_j ZddfVd `c T`_TVc_d cVXRcUZ_X eYV T`^aR_jod SfdZ_Vdd `c `aVcReZ`_d) >RZ]fcV e` cVa`ce dfdaVTeVU `c RTefR] gZ`]ReZ`_d Zd ZedV]W R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV R_U ^Rj dfS[VTe eYV Rdd`TZReV e` UZdTZa]Z_Rcj RTeZ`_' fa e` R_U Z_T]fUZ_X eVc^Z_ReZ`_ `W V^a]`j^V_e `c ]VXR] RTeZ`_) IVa`ced ^Rj SV ^RUV `_ R T`^a]VeV]j T`_WZUV_eZR] R_U R_`_j^`fd SRdZd) K` eYV VieV_e R_j Z_gVdeZXReZ`_ Zd _VTVddZeReVU Sj R cVa`ce' eYV T`^aR_j hZ]] V_UVRg`c e` \VVa eYV ac`TVVUZ_Xd R_U eYV ZUV_eZej `W eYV cVa`ceZ_X Rdd`TZReV T`_WZUV_eZR] e` eYV Wf]]Vde VieV_e cVbfZcVU Sj Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh) 8dd`TZReVd RcV V_T`fcRXVU e` afcdfV R]] Z_eVc_R] cVa`ceZ_X TYR__V]d eYc`fXY T`^a]VeZ`_ R_U cVRd`_RS]j RhRZe R_U T`_dZUVc eYV cVdf]ed `W R]] Z_eVc_R] Z_gVdeZXReZ`_d acZ`c e` cVa`ceZ_X ^ReeVcd `fedZUV `W eYV T`^aR_j) NV YRgV Z_deZefeVU eYV ac`TVUfcVd UVdTcZSVU Z_ eYZd ;`UV' Z_T]fUZ_X ac`TVUfcVd e` ^R\V R_`_j^`fd dfS^ZddZ`_d %R W`c^ `W Z_eVc_R] cVa`ce&' e` WRTZ]ZeReV eYV fdV `W Z_eVc_R] Z_gVdeZXReZ`_d) A_UZgZUfR]d dY`f]U R]d` T`_dZUVc ]VRgZ_X' Sfe RcV _`e cVbfZcVU e` ]VRgV' eYVZc _R^V `c R T`_eRTe _f^SVc hYV_ dfS^ZeeZ_X R cVa`ce) JfTY Z_W`c^ReZ`_ ^Rj WRTZ]ZeReV R ^`cV eY`c`fXY R_U VWWZTZV_e Z_gVdeZXReZ`_) KYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc hZ]] decZgV e` ^RZ_eRZ_ eYV Z_eVXcZej R_U T`_WZUV_eZR]Zej `W R]] T`^a]ZR_TV(cV]ReVU T`^^f_ZTReZ`_d) @`hVgVc' Z_ TVceRZ_ TZcTf^deR_TVd' eYV ZUV_eZej `W eYV aVcd`_ cVa`ceZ_X eYV ZddfV ^Rj SVT`^V \_`h_ `c ^Rj _VVU e` SV cVgVR]VU' aRceZTf]Rc]j ZW WVUVcR] `c deReV V_W`cTV^V_e RfeY`cZeZVd SVT`^V Z_g`]gVU Z_ eYV Z_gVdeZXReZ`_) KYV T`^aR_j TR__`e XfRcR_eVV T`_WZUV_eZR]Zej hYV_ ^ReVcZR] VgZUV_TV `W R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ]Rh Zd UZdT]`dVU `c ZW eYV aVcd`_ Zd ZUV_eZWZVU UfcZ_X eYV _`c^R] T`fcdV `W R_ Z_gVdeZXReZ`_) 8( MWXbc[TQ[^fTa 9^\_[XP]RT ?^c[X]T U^a 9^]UXST]cXP[ P]S 7]^]h\^db HT_^acX]V AW j`f RcV RhRcV `W R_j ScVRTY `W eYV ;`UV' j`f RcV `S]ZXReVU e` cVa`ce gZ`]ReZ`_d e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc' e` R_j ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' `c e` eYV R_`_j^`fd NYZde]VS]`hVc ;`^a]ZR_TV @`e]Z_V %eYV m@`e]Z_Vn&) O^d \Ph \PZT bdRW aT_^acb ^] P] P]^]h\^db P]S R^]UXST]cXP[ QPbXb Qh T\PX[X]V cWT ?^c[X]T) 8dd`TZReVd ^Rj cVa`ce e` eYV @`e]Z_V R_j T`_TVc_d R_ Rdd`TZReV ^Rj YRgV hZeY cVdaVTe e` eYV T`^aR_j' Z_T]fUZ_X' Sfe _`e ]Z^ZeVU e`' T`_TVc_d hZeY eYV T`^aR_jod SfdZ_Vdd `c `aVcReZ`_d' dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_d `W eYV ;`UV' dVTfcZeZVd `c R_eZWcRfU ]Rhd' RTT`f_eZ_X ZddfVd' R_j ]Rh cV]ReZ_X e` WcRfU RXRZ_de dYRcVY`]UVcd' `c R_j `eYVc ZddfV T`_TVc_Z_X eYV T`^aR_j R_U eYVZc V^a]`j^V_e hZeY eYV T`^aR_j) IVa`ced ^RUV e` eYV @`e]Z_V hZ]]' Z_ efc_' SV ac`gZUVU UZcVTe]j e` eYV 8fUZe ;`^^ZeeVV `_ R_ R_`_j^`fd R_U T`_WZUV_eZR] SRdZd) KYV @`e]Z_V ^Rj SV cVRTYVU -/ Y`fcd R URj' 2 URjd R hVV\ Re eYV W`]]`hZ_X V^RZ] RUUcVdd5 ,


 
<\PX[ PSSaTbb U^a cWT MWXbc[TQ[^fTa 9^\_[XP]RT ?^c[X]T3 ?^c[X]T <'\PX[ 7SSaTbb PdSXcR^\\XccTT6_XTaXb(R^\ 9( 7]cX'HTcP[XPcX^] F[TSVT 8_j Rdd`TZReV hY` Z_ X``U WRZeY cVa`ced R dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ f_UVc eYV ;`UV Sj eYV T`^aR_j' `c Zed RXV_ed RTeZ_X `_ SVYR]W `W eYV T`^aR_j' `c hY` Z_ X``U WRZeY cRZdVd ZddfVd `c T`_TVc_d cVXRcUZ_X eYV T`^aR_jod SfdZ_Vdd `c `aVcReZ`_d' e` eYV @`e]Z_V' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_j `eYVc ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' ^Rj _`e SV WZcVU' UV^`eVU' cVacZ^R_UVU `c `eYVchZdV YRc^VU W`c' `c SVTRfdV `W' eYV cVa`ceZ_X `W eYV dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_' ZddfVd `c T`_TVc_d' cVXRcU]Vdd `W hYVeYVc eYV dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ Z_g`]gVd eYV Rdd`TZReV' eYV Rdd`TZReVod dfaVcgZd`c `c dV_Z`c ^R_RXV^V_e `W eYV T`^aR_j) A_ RUUZeZ`_' R_j Rdd`TZReV hY` Z_ X``U WRZeY cVa`ced R dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ f_UVc eYV ;`UV hYZTY eYV Rdd`TZReV cVRd`_RS]j SV]ZVgVd T`_deZefeVd R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W R WVUVcR] deRefeV Sj eYV T`^aR_j' `c Zed RXV_ed RTeZ_X `_ SVYR]W `W eYV T`^aR_j' e` R WVUVcR] cVXf]Re`cj `c ]Rh V_W`cTV^V_e RXV_Tj' ^Rj _`e SV cVacZ^R_UVU' UZdTYRcXVU' UV^`eVU' dfdaV_UVU' eYcVReV_VU' YRcRddVU `c Z_ R_j ^R__Vc UZdTcZ^Z_ReVU RXRZ_de Z_ eYV eVc^d R_U T`_UZeZ`_d `W eYV Rdd`TZReVod V^a]`j^V_e W`c' `c SVTRfdV `W' eYV cVa`ceZ_X `W eYV dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_' cVXRcU]Vdd `W hYVeYVc eYV dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ Z_g`]gVd eYV Rdd`TZReV' eYV Rdd`TZReVod dfaVcgZd`c `c dV_Z`c ^R_RXV^V_e `W eYV T`^aR_j) @@( @CFB<C<DJ7J@ED E= J?< 9E;< KYV W`]]`hZ_X bfVdeZ`_d R_U R_dhVcd RUUcVdd eYV T`^aR_jod Z^a]V^V_eReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV) KYV T`^aR_j YRd ReeV^aeVU e` UVdZX_ ac`TVUfcVd eYRe V_dfcV ^RiZ^f^ T`_WZUV_eZR]Zej' R_`_j^Zej' R_U' ^`de Z^a`ceR_e]j' WcVVU`^ Wc`^ eYV WVRc `W cVeR]ZReZ`_ W`c T`^a]jZ_X hZeY R_U cVa`ceZ_X gZ`]ReZ`_d f_UVc eYV ;`UV) A_ RUUZeZ`_' VRTY Rdd`TZReV dYR]] dZX_ eYV 8dd`TZReVod 8XcVV^V_e e` ;`^a]j hZeY eYV ;`UV Z_ dfSdeR_eZR]]j eYV W`c^ ReeRTYVU Rd 8aaV_UZi 8 YVcVe`) G3 MW^ Xb aTb_^]bXQ[T U^a PS\X]XbcTaX]V& d_SPcX]V P]S T]U^aRX]V cWT 9^ST5 73 KYV T`^aR_jod 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd YRd Raa`Z_eVU R ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc R_U R ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV eYRe Z_T]fUVd eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc R_U Re ]VRde `_V RUUZeZ`_R] ^V^SVc e` RU^Z_ZdeVc' faUReV R_U V_W`cTV eYV ;`UV) L]eZ^ReV]j' eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `W eYV T`^aR_j ^fde V_dfcV eYRe eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc R_U eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV Wf]WZ]] eYVZc cVda`_dZSZ]ZeZVd) KYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc YRd `gVcR]] cVda`_dZSZ]Zej W`c `gVcdVVZ_X eYV Z^a]V^V_eReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV) JaVTZWZT cVda`_dZSZ]ZeZVd `W eYV a`dZeZ`_ RcV e`5 " <VgV]`a eYV ;`UV SRdVU `_ ]VXR] cVbfZcV^V_ed' cVXf]ReZ`_d R_U VeYZTR] T`_dZUVcReZ`_d eYRe RcV cRZdVU Z_ eYV T`^aR_jod `aVcReZ`_d6 " =_dfcV eYRe eYV ;`UV Zd UZdecZSfeVU e` R]] Rdd`TZReVd R_U eYRe R]] Rdd`TZReVd RT\_`h]VUXV eYV acZ_TZa]Vd `W eYV ;`UV6 -


 
" N`c\ hZeY eYV T`^aR_jod 8fUZe ;`^^ZeeVV e` ac`gZUV R cVa`ceZ_X ^VTYR_Zd^ d` eYRe Rdd`TZReVd YRgV R T`_WZUV_eZR] R_U R_`_j^`fd ^VeY`U `W cVa`ceZ_X _`e `_]j dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_d `W eYV ;`UV Sfe T`_TVc_d cVXRcUZ_X WVUVcR] dVTfcZeZVd `c R_eZWcRfU ]Rhd' RTT`f_eZ_X ZddfVd' `c R_j WVUVcR] ]Rh cV]ReZ_X e` WcRfU RXRZ_de dYRcVY`]UVcd6 " A^a]V^V_e R ecRZ_Z_X ac`XcR^ e` V_dfcV eYRe Rdd`TZReVd RcV RhRcV `W R_U f_UVcdeR_U eYV ;`UV6 " 8fUZe R_U RddVdd T`^a]ZR_TV hZeY eYV ;`UV6 " JVcgV Rd R a`Z_e aVcd`_ W`c cVa`ceZ_X gZ`]ReZ`_d R_U Rd\Z_X bfVdeZ`_d f_UVc eYV ;`UV6 R_U " IVgZdV R_U faUReV eYV ;`UV Rd _VTVddRcj e` cVda`_U e` UVeVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_d R_U TYR_XVd Z_ eYV ]Rh) KYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV Zd T`^acZdVU `W eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc' R_U Re ]VRde `_V RUUZeZ`_R] ^V^SVc dV]VTeVU Wc`^ R cVacVdV_eReZgV Wc`^ eYV @f^R_ IVd`fcTVd <VaRce^V_e' R cVacVdV_eReZgV Wc`^ eYV >Z_R_TV <VaRce^V_e' R cVacVdV_eReZgV Wc`^ eYV CVXR] <VaRce^V_e R_U*`c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ViVTfeZgV ^R_RXV^V_e eVR^) KYV acZ^Rcj cVda`_dZSZ]ZeZVd `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV RcV e`5 " 8ddZde eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc Z_ UVgV]`aZ_X R_U faUReZ_X eYV ;`UV6 " <VgV]`a Z_eVc_R] ac`TVUfcVd e` ^`_Ze`c R_U RfUZe T`^a]ZR_TV hZeY eYV ;`UV6 " JVcgV Rd a`Z_e aVcd`_d W`c cVa`ceZ_X gZ`]ReZ`_d R_U Rd\Z_X bfVdeZ`_d f_UVc eYV ;`UV6 " JVe fa R ^VTYR_Zd^ W`c R_`_j^`fd cVa`ceZ_X `W dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_d `W eYV ;`UV Sj Rdd`TZReVd R_U cVWVc' hYV_ Raac`acZReV' dfTY cVa`ced e` eYV 8fUZe ;`^^ZeeVV6 " ;`_UfTe Z_eVc_R] Z_gVdeZXReZ`_d' hZeY eYV RddZdeR_TV `W T`f_dV]' `W dfdaVTeVU T`^a]ZR_TV gZ`]ReZ`_d6 " =gR]fReV UZdTZa]Z_Rcj RTeZ`_ W`c Rdd`TZReVd hY` gZ`]ReV eYV ;`UV6 " A_ eYV TRdV `W ^`cV dVgVcV gZ`]ReZ`_d `W eYV ;`UV' ^R\V cVT`^^V_UReZ`_d cVXRcUZ_X UZdTZa]Z_Rcj RTeZ`_ e` eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `c R T`^^ZeeVV eYVcV`W6 R_U " =gR]fReV eYV VWWVTeZgV_Vdd `W eYV ;`UV R_U Z^ac`gV eYV ;`UV) KYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV hZ]] ac`gZUV R df^^Rcj `W R]] ^ReeVcd T`_dZUVcVU f_UVc eYV ;`UV e` eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `c R T`^^ZeeVV eYVcV`W Re VRTY cVXf]Rc ^VVeZ_X eYVcV`W' `c d``_Vc ZW hRccR_eVU Sj eYV dVgVcZej `W eYV ^ReeVc) 8]] ac`TVVUZ_Xd R_U eYV ZUV_eZej `W eYV aVcd`_ cVa`ceZ_X hZ]] SV \Vae T`_WZUV_eZR] e` eYV VieV_e cVbfZcVU Sj Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh) G3 ?^f RP] @ R^]cPRc cWT 9^a_^aPcT 9^\_[XP]RT EUUXRTa P]S cWT 9^\_[XP]RT 9^\\XccTT5 73 KYV _R^Vd' V^RZ] RUUcVddVd R_U aY`_V _f^SVcd `W eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc R_U VRTY ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV RcV ]ZdeVU SV]`h) 8_j `_V `W eYVdV Z_UZgZUfR]d TR_ RddZde j`f Z_ R_dhVcZ_X bfVdeZ`_d `c cVa`ceZ_X gZ`]ReZ`_d `c dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_d f_UVc eYV ;`UV) .


 
7W\TS C^dbP& LF BXRT]bX]V& @F " BTVP[ 7UUPXab %*'1.0'+.)'),/, ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc \^dbP6_XTaXb(R^\ 7[[P] HTX]T& ILF " 9=E %*'1.0'+-/'1221 ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV DV^SVc cVZ_V7aZVcZd)T`^ KYV ^V^SVcd `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV ^Rj TYR_XV Wc`^ eZ^V e` eZ^V) P`f RcV V_T`fcRXVU e` T`_df]e eYV T`aj `W eYV ;`UV eYRe Zd Z_T]fUVU `_ eYV T`^aR_jod hVSdZeV e` `SeRZ_ eYV ^`de TfccV_e ^V^SVcdYZa `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) @@@( ><D<H7B H<GK@H<C<DJI =RTY Rdd`TZReV `W eYV T`^aR_j Zd ViaVTeVU e` SV Y`_Vde' WRZc' R_U RTT`f_eRS]V Z_ R]] SfdZ_Vdd UVR]Z_Xd R_U `S]ZXReZ`_d' R_U e` V_dfcV5 " eYV VeYZTR] YR_U]Z_X `W T`_W]ZTed `W Z_eVcVde SVehVV_ aVcd`_R] R_U ac`WVddZ`_R] cV]ReZ`_dYZad6 " Wf]]' WRZc' RTTfcReV' eZ^V]j R_U f_UVcdeR_URS]V UZdT]`dfcV Z_ eYV cVa`ced cVbfZcVU e` SV WZ]VU Sj eYV T`^aR_j hZeY eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_ R_U Z_ `eYVc afS]ZT T`^^f_ZTReZ`_d ^RUV Sj eYV T`^aR_j6 R_U " T`^a]ZR_TV hZeY Raa]ZTRS]V X`gVc_^V_eR] ]Rhd' cf]Vd R_U cVXf]ReZ`_d) @L( 9ED=B@9JI E= @DJ<H<IJ 8dd`TZReVd dY`f]U Rg`ZU R_j dZefReZ`_ eYRe ^Rj Z_g`]gV' `c VgV_ RaaVRc e` Z_g`]gV' R T`_W]ZTe SVehVV_ eYVZc aVcd`_R] Z_eVcVded R_U eYV Z_eVcVded `W eYV T`^aR_j) A_ UVR]Z_Xd hZeY TfccV_e `c a`eV_eZR] Tfde`^Vcd' dfaa]ZVcd' T`_ecRTe`cd' R_U T`^aVeZe`cd' VRTY Rdd`TZReV dY`f]U RTe Z_ eYV SVde Z_eVcVded `W eYV T`^aR_j e` eYV ViT]fdZ`_ `W aVcd`_R] RUgR_eRXV) A^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVcd `W Rdd`TZReVd' ViVTfeZgV `WWZTVcd R_U UZcVTe`cd RcV R]d` T`gVcVU Z_ TVceRZ_ TZcTf^deR_TVd) >`c afca`dVd `W eYZd dVTeZ`_' R mdZX_ZWZTR_en R^`f_e `c Z_eVcVde dYR]] SV UVV^VU e` SV R_j R^`f_e Z_ ViTVdd `W ",-+'+++ R_U R_ mZ^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVcn Z_ cVdaVTe `W R_j aVcd`_ ^VR_d R_j TYZ]U' deVaTYZ]U' aRcV_e' deVaaRcV_e' da`fdV' dZS]Z_X' ^`eYVc(Z_(]Rh' WReYVc(Z_(]Rh' d`_(Z_(]Rh' URfXYeVc(Z_(]Rh' Sc`eYVc(Z_(]Rh' `c dZdeVc(Z_(]Rh `W dfTY aVcd`_' R_U R_j aVcd`_ %`eYVc eYR_ R eV_R_e `c V^a]`jVV& dYRcZ_X eYV Y`fdVY`]U `W dfTY aVcd`_) 8dd`TZReVd R_U' Z_ TVceRZ_ TZcTf^deR_TVd' eYVZc Z^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVcd' RcV ac`YZSZeVU Wc`^ R_j `W eYV W`]]`hZ_X RTeZgZeZVd hYZTY T`f]U cVacVdV_e R_ RTefR] `c aVcTVZgVU T`_W]ZTe `W Z_eVcVde5 " E` Rdd`TZReV `c Z^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVc `W R_ Rdd`TZReV dYR]] YRgV R dZX_ZWZTR_e WZ_R_TZR] Z_eVcVde Z_' `c `S]ZXReZ`_ e`' R_j `fedZUV V_eVcacZdV hYZTY U`Vd `c dVV\d e` U` SfdZ_Vdd hZeY eYV T`^aR_j `c hYZTY Zd R_ RTefR] `c a`eV_eZR] T`^aVeZe`c `W eYV T`^aR_j' hZeY`fe acZ`c Raac`gR] `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' `c Z_ eYV TRdV `W ViVTfeZgV `WWZTVcd `c ^V^SVcd `W eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd' eYV Wf]] 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `c R T`^^ZeeVV eYVcV`W6 ac`gZUVU Y`hVgVc' eYRe eYZd ac`gZdZ`_ dYR]] _`e acVgV_e R_j /


 
Rdd`TZReV Wc`^ Z_gVdeZ_X Z_ R_j ^fefR] Wf_U `c `h_Z_X fa e` ,# `W eYV `fedeR_UZ_X de`T\ `W R_j afS]ZT]j ecRUVU T`^aR_j) " E` Rdd`TZReV dYR]] T`_UfTe R dZX_ZWZTR_e R^`f_e `W SfdZ_Vdd `_ eYV T`^aR_jod SVYR]W hZeY R_ `fedZUV V_eVcacZdV hYZTY U`Vd `c dVV\d e` U` SfdZ_Vdd hZeY eYV T`^aR_j ZW R_ Z^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVc `W eYV Rdd`TZReV Zd R acZ_TZaR] `c `WWZTVc `W dfTY V_eVcacZdV' `c R_ V^a]`jVV `W dfTY V_eVcacZdV hY` hZ]] a]Rj R dZX_ZWZTR_e c`]V Z_ eYV SfdZ_Vdd U`_V `c e` SV U`_V SVehVV_ eYV T`^aR_j R_U dfTY V_eVcacZdV' hZeY`fe acZ`c Raac`gR] `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' `c Z_ eYV TRdV `W ViVTfeZgV `WWZTVcd `c ^V^SVcd `W eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd' eYV Wf]] 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `c R T`^^ZeeVV eYVcV`W) " E` ViVTfeZgV `WWZTVc `c V^a]`jVV' `c R_ Z^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVc `W R_ ViVTfeZgV `WWZTVc `c R_ V^a]`jVV' dYR]] dVcgV Rd R UZcVTe`c' `WWZTVc `c Z_ R_j `eYVc ^R_RXV^V_e `c T`_df]eZ_X TRaRTZej `W R_j RTefR] T`^aVeZe`c `W eYV T`^aR_j) " E` UZcVTe`c' `c R_ Z^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVc `W R UZcVTe`c' dYR]] dVcgV Rd R UZcVTe`c' `WWZTVc `c Z_ R_j `eYVc ^R_RXV^V_e `c T`_df]eZ_X TRaRTZej `W R_j RTefR] T`^aVeZe`c `W eYV T`^aR_j' hZeY`fe eYV acZ`c Raac`gR] `W eYV Wf]] 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `c R T`^^ZeeVV eYVcV`W) " E` Rdd`TZReV dYR]] fdV R_j T`^aR_j ac`aVcej `c Z_W`c^ReZ`_ `c YZd `c YVc a`dZeZ`_ Re eYV T`^aR_j W`c YZd `c YVc aVcd`_R] XRZ_) " E` Rdd`TZReV dYR]] V_XRXV Z_ RTeZgZeZVd eYRe RcV UZcVTe]j T`^aVeZeZgV hZeY eY`dV Z_ hYZTY eYV T`^aR_j Zd V_XRXVU) " E` Rdd`TZReV dYR]] UZgVce R SfdZ_Vdd `aa`cef_Zej Wc`^ eYV T`^aR_j e` dfTY Z_UZgZUfR]od `h_ SV_VWZe) AW R_ Rdd`TZReV SVT`^Vd RhRcV `W R_ `aa`cef_Zej e` RTbfZcV `c ac`WZe Wc`^ R SfdZ_Vdd `aa`cef_Zej `c Z_gVde^V_e Z_ hYZTY eYV T`^aR_j Zd `c ^Rj SVT`^V Z_g`]gVU `c Z_ hYZTY eYV T`^aR_j ^Rj YRgV R_ ViZdeZ_X Z_eVcVde' eYV Rdd`TZReV dY`f]U UZdT]`dV eYV cV]VgR_e WRTed e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) KYV Rdd`TZReV ^Rj ac`TVVU e` eR\V RUgR_eRXV `W dfTY `aa`cef_Zej `_]j ZW eYV T`^aR_j Zd f_hZ]]Z_X `c f_RS]V e` eR\V RUgR_eRXV `W dfTY `aa`cef_Zej Rd _`eZWZVU Z_ hcZeZ_X Sj eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) " E` Rdd`TZReV `c Z^^VUZReV WR^Z]j ^V^SVc `W R_ Rdd`TZReV dYR]] cVTVZgV R_j ]`R_ `c RUgR_TV Wc`^ eYV T`^aR_j' `c SV eYV SV_VWZTZRcj `W R XfRcR_eVV Sj eYV T`^aR_j `W R ]`R_ `c RUgR_TV Wc`^ R eYZcU aRcej' ViTVae W`c Tfde`^Rcj RUgR_TVd `c T`ca`cReV TcVUZe Z_ eYV `cUZ_Rcj T`fcdV `W SfdZ_Vdd `c Raac`gVU Sj eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) G]VRdV dVV JVTeZ`_ M)=) SV]`h' m;`ca`cReV 8UgR_TVdn' W`c ^`cV Z_W`c^ReZ`_ `_ aVc^ZeeVU T`ca`cReV RUgR_TVd) A_ RUUZeZ`_' eYV 8fUZe ;`^^ZeeVV `W eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd hZ]] cVgZVh R_U Raac`gV' Z_ RUgR_TV' R]] cV]ReVU(aVcd`_ ecR_dRTeZ`_d' Rd cVbfZcVU Sj eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_' KYV ERdURb Je`T\ DRc\Ve `c R_j `eYVc cVXf]Re`cj S`Uj e` hYZTY eYV T`^aR_j Zd dfS[VTe) 0


 
=RTY Rdd`TZReV dY`f]U ^R\V ac`^ae R_U Wf]] UZdT]`dfcV Z_ hcZeZ_X e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV `W R_j dZefReZ`_ eYRe ^Rj Z_g`]gV R T`_W]ZTe `W Z_eVcVde) >RZ]fcV e` UZdT]`dV R_j RTefR] `c aVcTVZgVU T`_W]ZTe `W Z_eVcVde Zd R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV) L( FHEJ<9J@ED 7D; FHEF<H KI< E= 9ECF7DO 7II<JI Gc`aVc ac`eVTeZ`_ R_U fdV `W T`^aR_j RddVed R_U RddVed V_ecfdeVU e` Ze Sj `eYVcd' Z_T]fUZ_X ac`acZVeRcj Z_W`c^ReZ`_' Zd R Wf_UR^V_eR] cVda`_dZSZ]Zej `W VRTY Rdd`TZReV `W eYV T`^aR_j) 8dd`TZReVd ^fde T`^a]j hZeY dVTfcZej ac`XcR^d e` dRWVXfRcU dfTY RddVed RXRZ_de f_RfeY`cZkVU fdV `c cV^`gR]' Rd hV]] Rd RXRZ_de ]`dd Sj TcZ^Z_R] RTe `c ScVRTY `W ecfde) KYV ac`gZdZ`_d YVcV`W cV]ReZ_X e` ac`eVTeZ`_ `W eYV T`^aR_jod ac`aVcej R]d` Raa]j e` ac`aVcej `W `eYVcd V_ecfdeVU e` Ze %Z_T]fUZ_X ac`acZVeRcj R_U T`_WZUV_eZR] Z_W`c^ReZ`_&) 7( Fa^_Ta KbT ^U 9^\_P]h Fa^_Tach KYV cV^`gR] Wc`^ eYV T`^aR_jod WRTZ]ZeZVd `W eYV T`^aR_jod ac`aVcej Zd ac`YZSZeVU' f_]Vdd RfeY`cZkVU Sj eYV T`^aR_j) KYZd Raa]ZVd e` Wfc_ZdYZ_Xd' VbfZa^V_e' R_U dfaa]ZVd' Rd hV]] Rd ac`aVcej TcVReVU `c `SeRZ_VU Sj eYV T`^aR_j W`c Zed ViT]fdZgV fdV l dfTY Rd T]ZV_e ]Zded' WZ]Vd' aVcd`__V] Z_W`c^ReZ`_' cVWVcV_TV ^ReVcZR]d R_U cVa`ced' T`^afeVc d`WehRcV' UReR ac`TVddZ_X ac`XcR^d R_U UReR SRdVd) EVZeYVc `cZXZ_R]d _`c T`aZVd `W eYVdV ^ReVcZR]d ^Rj SV cV^`gVU Wc`^ eYV T`^aR_jod acV^ZdVd `c fdVU W`c afca`dVd `eYVc eYR_ eYV T`^aR_jod SfdZ_Vdd hZeY`fe acZ`c hcZeeV_ RfeY`cZkReZ`_ Wc`^ eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) KYV T`^aR_jod ac`UfTed R_U dVcgZTVd RcV Zed ac`aVcej6 T`_ecZSfeZ`_d ^RUV Sj R_j Rdd`TZReV e` eYVZc UVgV]`a^V_e R_U Z^a]V^V_eReZ`_ RcV eYV T`^aR_jod ac`aVcej R_U cV^RZ_ eYV T`^aR_jod ac`aVcej VgV_ ZW eYV Z_UZgZUfR]od V^a]`j^V_e `c UZcVTe`cdYZa eVc^Z_ReVd) =RTY Rdd`TZReV YRd R_ `S]ZXReZ`_ e` fdV eYV eZ^V W`c hYZTY YV `c dYV cVTVZgVd T`^aV_dReZ`_ Wc`^ eYV T`^aR_j ac`UfTeZgV]j) N`c\ Y`fcd dY`f]U SV UVg`eVU e` RTeZgZeZVd UZcVTe]j cV]ReVU e` eYV T`^aR_jod SfdZ_Vdd) 8( 9^]UXST]cXP[ @]U^a\PcX^] KYV T`^aR_j ac`gZUVd Zed Rdd`TZReVd hZeY T`_WZUV_eZR] Z_W`c^ReZ`_ cV]ReZ_X e` eYV T`^aR_j R_U Zed SfdZ_Vdd hZeY eYV f_UVcdeR_UZ_X eYRe dfTY Z_W`c^ReZ`_ Zd e` SV YV]U Z_ T`_WZUV_TV R_U _`e T`^^f_ZTReVU e` R_j`_V hY` Zd _`e RfeY`cZkVU e` dVV Ze' ViTVae Rd ^Rj SV cVbfZcVU Sj ]Rh) KYV ejaVd `W Z_W`c^ReZ`_ eYRe VRTY Rdd`TZReV ^fde dRWVXfRcU Z_T]fUV %Sfe RcV _`e ]Z^ZeVU e`& eYV T`^aR_jod a]R_d R_U SfdZ_Vdd decReVXj' f_R__`f_TVU ac`UfTed R_U*`c T`_ecRTed' dR]Vd UReR' dZX_ZWZTR_e ac`[VTed' Tfde`^Vc R_U dfaa]ZVc ]Zded' aReV_ed' aReV_e Raa]ZTReZ`_d' ecRUV dVTcVed' ^R_fWRTefcZ_X eVTY_ZbfVd R_U dV_dZeZgV WZ_R_TZR] Z_W`c^ReZ`_' hYVeYVc Z_ V]VTec`_ZT `c aRaVc W`c^Re) KYVdV RcV T`de]j' gR]fRS]V cVd`fcTVd UVgV]`aVU W`c eYV ViT]fdZgV SV_VWZe `W eYV T`^aR_j) E` Rdd`TZReV dYR]] UZdT]`dV eYV T`^aR_jod T`_WZUV_eZR] Z_W`c^ReZ`_ e` R_ f_RfeY`cZkVU eYZcU aRcej `c fdV eYV T`^aR_jod T`_WZUV_eZR] Z_W`c^ReZ`_ W`c YZd `c YVc `h_ aVcd`_R] SV_VWZe) 9( 7RRdaPcT HTR^aSb P]S HT_^acX]V 1


 
L_UVc ]Rh' eYV T`^aR_j Zd cVbfZcVU e` \VVa S``\d' cVT`cUd R_U RTT`f_ed eYRe RTTfcReV]j R_U WRZc]j cVW]VTe R]] ecR_dRTeZ`_d' UZda`dZeZ`_d `W RddVed R_U `eYVc VgV_ed eYRe RcV eYV dfS[VTe `W daVTZWZT cVXf]Re`cj cVT`cU \VVaZ_X cVbfZcV^V_ed' Z_T]fUZ_X XV_VcR]]j RTTVaeVU RTT`f_eZ_X acZ_TZa]Vd R_U `eYVc Raa]ZTRS]V cf]Vd' cVXf]ReZ`_d R_U TcZeVcZR W`c acVaRcZ_X WZ_R_TZR] deReV^V_ed R_U W`c acVaRcZ_X aVcZ`UZT cVa`ced WZ]VU hZeY eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_) 8]] T`^aR_j cVa`ced' RTT`f_eZ_X cVT`cUd' dR]Vd cVa`ced' ViaV_dV RTT`f_ed' Z_g`ZTVd' afcTYRdV `cUVcd' R_U `eYVc U`Tf^V_ed ^fde RTTfcReV]j R_U T]VRc]j cVacVdV_e eYV cV]VgR_e WRTed R_U eYV ecfV _RefcV `W ecR_dRTeZ`_d) IVa`ced R_U `eYVc U`Tf^V_ed dY`f]U deReV R]] ^ReVcZR] WRTed `W R ecR_dRTeZ`_ R_U _`e `^Ze R_j Z_W`c^ReZ`_ eYRe h`f]U SV cV]VgR_e Z_ Z_eVcacVeZ_X dfTY cVa`ce `c U`Tf^V_e) L_UVc _` TZcTf^deR_TV ^Rj eYVcV SV R_j f_cVT`cUVU ]ZRSZ]Zej `c Wf_U `W eYV T`^aR_j' cVXRcU]Vdd `W eYV afca`dVd W`c hYZTY eYV ]ZRSZ]Zej `c Wf_U ^Rj YRgV SVV_ Z_eV_UVU' `c R_j Z^ac`aVc `c Z_RTTfcReV V_ecj \_`hZ_X]j ^RUV `_ eYV S``\d `c cVT`cUd `W eYV T`^aR_j) E` aRj^V_e `_ SVYR]W `W eYV T`^aR_j ^Rj SV Raac`gVU `c ^RUV hZeY eYV Z_eV_eZ`_' f_UVcdeR_UZ_X `c RhRcV_Vdd eYRe R_j aRce `W eYV aRj^V_e Zd e` SV fdVU W`c R_j afca`dV `eYVc eYR_ eYRe UVdTcZSVU Sj eYV U`Tf^V_eReZ`_ dfaa`ceZ_X eYV aRj^V_e) A_ RUUZeZ`_' Z_eV_eZ`_R] RTT`f_eZ_X ^ZdT]RddZWZTReZ`_d %V)X)' ViaV_dV gVcdfd TRaZeR]& R_U Z^ac`aVc RTTV]VcReZ`_ `c UVWVccR] `W ViaV_dVd `c cVgV_fVd RcV f_RTTVaeRS]V cVa`ceZ_X acRTeZTVd eYRe RcV ViacVdd]j ac`YZSZeVU) KYV T`^aR_j YRd UVgV]`aVU R_U ^RZ_eRZ_d R djdeV^ `W Z_eVc_R] T`_ec`]d e` ac`gZUV cVRd`_RS]V RddfcR_TV eYRe ecR_dRTeZ`_d RcV ViVTfeVU Z_ RTT`cUR_TV hZeY ^R_RXV^V_eod RfeY`cZkReZ`_' RcV ac`aVc]j cVT`cUVU R_U a`deVU' R_U RcV Z_ T`^a]ZR_TV hZeY cVXf]Re`cj cVbfZcV^V_ed) KYV djdeV^ `W Z_eVc_R] T`_ec`]d hZeYZ_ eYV T`^aR_j Z_T]fUVd hcZeeV_ a`]ZTZVd R_U ac`TVUfcVd' SfUXVeRcj T`_ec`]d' dfaVcgZd`cj cVgZVh R_U ^`_Ze`cZ_X' R_U gRcZ`fd `eYVc TYVT\d R_U SR]R_TVd' R_U dRWVXfRcUd' dfTY Rd aRddh`cU ac`eVTeZ`_ e` RTTVdd TVceRZ_ T`^afeVc djdeV^d) KYV T`^aR_j YRd R]d` UVgV]`aVU R_U ^RZ_eRZ_d R dVe `W UZdT]`dfcV T`_ec`]d R_U ac`TVUfcVd e` V_dfcV eYRe R]] `W eYV Z_W`c^ReZ`_ cVbfZcVU e` SV UZdT]`dVU Sj eYV T`^aR_j Z_ eYV cVa`ced eYRe Ze WZ]Vd `c dfS^Zed f_UVc eYV JVTfcZeZVd =iTYR_XV 8Te Zd cVT`cUVU' ac`TVddVU' df^^RcZkVU R_U cVa`ceVU hZeYZ_ eYV eZ^V aVcZ`Ud daVTZWZVU Sj eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_od cf]Vd R_U W`c^d) 8dd`TZReVd RcV ViaVTeVU e` SV WR^Z]ZRc hZeY' R_U e` RUYVcV decZTe]j e`' eYVdV Z_eVc_R] T`_ec`]d R_U UZdT]`dfcV T`_ec`]d R_U ac`TVUfcVd) IVda`_dZSZ]Zej W`c T`^a]ZR_TV hZeY eYVdV Z_eVc_R] T`_ec`]d R_U UZdT]`dfcV T`_ec`]d R_U ac`TVUfcVd cVded _`e d`]V]j hZeY eYV T`^aR_jod RTT`f_eZ_X aVcd`__V]' Sfe hZeY R]] Rdd`TZReVd Z_g`]gVU Z_ Raac`gZ_X ecR_dRTeZ`_d' dfaa]jZ_X U`Tf^V_eReZ`_ W`c ecR_dRTeZ`_d' R_U cVT`cUZ_X' ac`TVddZ_X' df^^RcZkZ_X R_U cVa`ceZ_X `W ecR_dRTeZ`_d R_U `eYVc Z_W`c^ReZ`_ cVbfZcVU Sj aVcZ`UZT cVa`ced WZ]VU hZeY eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_) 8TRPdbT cWT X]cTVaXch ^U cWT R^\_P]hkb TgcTa]P[ aT_^acb c^ bWPaTW^[STab P]S cWT ITRdaXcXTb P]S <gRWP]VT 9^\\XbbX^] ST_T]Sb ^] cWT X]cTVaXch ^U cWT R^\_P]hkb X]cTa]P[ aT_^acb P]S aTR^aS'ZTT_X]V& P[[ Pbb^RXPcTb \dbc PSWTaT c^ cWT WXVWTbc bcP]SPaSb ^U RPaT fXcW aTb_TRc c^ ^da X]cTa]P[ aTR^aSb P]S aT_^acX]V( JWT R^\_P]h Xb R^\\XccTS c^ Ud[[& UPXa& PRRdaPcT& cX\T[h& P]S d]STabcP]SPQ[T SXbR[^bdaT X] cWT _TaX^SXR aT_^acb aT`dXaTS c^ QT UX[TS Qh Xc fXcW cWT ITRdaXcXTb P]S <gRWP]VT 9^\\XbbX^]& P]S Xc Tg_TRcb TPRW Pbb^RXPcT c^ f^aZ SX[XVT]c[h c^fPaSb cWPc V^P[( 2


 
8_j Rdd`TZReV hY` SV]ZVgVd eYV T`^aR_jod S``\d R_U cVT`cUd RcV _`e Z_ RTT`cU hZeY eYVdV cVbfZcV^V_ed dY`f]U Z^^VUZReV]j cVa`ce eYV ^ReeVc e` eYV @`e]Z_V' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) KYV T`^aR_j YRd RU`aeVU Via]ZTZe R_eZ( cVeR]ZReZ`_ a`]ZTZVd hZeY cVdaVTe e` eYVdV ^ReeVcd' Rd UVdTcZSVU Z_ JVTeZ`_ A RS`gV) ;( ;^Rd\T]c HTcT]cX^] Ef^Vc`fd WVUVcR] R_U deReV deRefeVd cVbfZcV eYV ac`aVc cVeV_eZ`_ `W ^R_j TReVX`cZVd `W cVT`cUd R_U U`Tf^V_ed eYRe RcV T`^^`_]j ^RZ_eRZ_VU Sj T`^aR_ZVd) A_ T`_dZUVcReZ`_ `W eY`dV ]VXR] cVbfZcV^V_ed R_U eYV T`^aR_jod SfdZ_Vdd _VVUd' R]] Rdd`TZReVd ^fde ^RZ_eRZ_ cVT`cUd Z_ RTT`cUR_TV hZeY eYVdV ]Rhd R_U' ZW R_j' eYV T`^aR_jod U`Tf^V_e cVeV_eZ`_ a`]ZTj) 8_j cVT`cU' Z_ aRaVc `c V]VTec`_ZT W`c^Re' cV]VgR_e e` R eYcVReV_VU' R_eZTZaReVU `c RTefR] Z_eVc_R] `c VieVc_R] Z_bfZcj' Z_gVdeZXReZ`_' ^ReeVc `c ]RhdfZe ^Rj _`e SV UZdTRcUVU' T`_TVR]VU' WR]dZWZVU' R]eVcVU' `c `eYVchZdV ^RUV f_RgRZ]RS]V' `_TV R_ Rdd`TZReV YRd SVT`^V RhRcV `W eYV ViZdeV_TV `W dfTY eYcVReV_VU' R_eZTZaReVU `c RTefR] Z_eVc_R] `c VieVc_R] Z_bfZcj' Z_gVdeZXReZ`_' ^ReeVc `c ]RhdfZe( NYV_ Z_ U`fSe cVXRcUZ_X cVeV_eZ`_ `W R_j cVT`cU' R_ Rdd`TZReV ^fde _`e UZdTRcU `c R]eVc eYV cVT`cU Z_ bfVdeZ`_ R_U dY`f]U dVV\ XfZUR_TV Wc`^ eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) 8dd`TZReVd dY`f]U R]d` UZcVTe R]] bfVdeZ`_d cVXRcUZ_X U`Tf^V_e cVeV_eZ`_ R_U cV]ReVU ac`TVUfcVd e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) <( 9^a_^aPcT 7SeP]RTb L_UVc ]Rh' eYV T`^aR_j ^Rj _`e ]`R_ ^`_Vj e` Rdd`TZReVd ViTVae Z_ ]Z^ZeVU TZcTf^deR_TVd) Ae dYR]] SV R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV W`c R_j Rdd`TZReV e` RUgR_TV T`^aR_j Wf_Ud e` R_j `eYVc Rdd`TZReV `c e` YZ^dV]W `c YVcdV]W ViTVae W`c fdfR] R_U Tfde`^Rcj SfdZ_Vdd RUgR_TVd W`c ]VXZeZ^ReV T`ca`cReV afca`dVd hYZTY RcV Raac`gVU Sj R dfaVcgZd`c `c afcdfR_e e` R T`ca`cReV TcVUZe TRcU W`c fdfR] R_U Tfde`^Rcj' ]VXZeZ^ReV SfdZ_Vdd afca`dVd) Ae Zd eYV T`^aR_jod a`]ZTj eYRe R_j RUgR_TV e` R_ Rdd`TZReV _`e ^VVeZ_X eYV W`cX`Z_X TcZeVcZR SV Raac`gVU Z_ RUgR_TV Sj eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) ;`^aR_j TcVUZe TRcUd RcV e` SV fdVU `_]j W`c RfeY`cZkVU' ]VXZeZ^ReV SfdZ_Vdd afca`dVd) 8_ Rdd`TZReV hZ]] SV cVda`_dZS]V W`c R_j f_RfeY`cZkVU TYRcXVd e` R T`^aR_j TcVUZe TRcU) L@( =7@H ;<7B@D> M@J? 9KIJEC<HI& IKFFB@<HI& 9ECF<J@JEHI& 7D; 7IIE9@7J<I KYV T`^aR_j U`Vd _`e dVV\ e` XRZ_ R_j RUgR_eRXV eYc`fXY eYV Z^ac`aVc fdV `W WRg`cd `c `eYVc Z_UfTV^V_ed) ?``U [fUX^V_e R_U ^`UVcReZ`_ ^fde SV ViVcTZdVU e` Rg`ZU ^ZdZ_eVcacVeReZ`_ R_U RUgVcdV VWWVTe `_ eYV cVafeReZ`_ `W eYV T`^aR_j `c Zed Rdd`TZReVd) FWWVcZ_X' XZgZ_X' d`]ZTZeZ_X `c cVTVZgZ_X R_j W`c^ `W ScZSV e` `c Wc`^ R_ V^a]`jVV `W R Tfde`^Vc `c dfaa]ZVc e` Z_W]fV_TV eYRe V^a]`jVVod T`_UfTe Zd decZTe]j ac`YZSZeVU) 3


 
7( >XeX]V >XUcb ;RdY `c TRdY(VbfZgR]V_e XZWed ^fde _`e SV XZgV_ Sj R_ Rdd`TZReV e` R_j aVcd`_ `c V_eVcacZdV) ?ZWed' WRg`cd R_U V_eVceRZ_^V_e ^Rj SV XZgV_ e` _`_(X`gVc_^V_eR] V^a]`jVVd ZW hYRe Zd XZgV_5 " Zd T`_dZdeV_e hZeY Tfde`^Rcj SfdZ_Vdd acRTeZTV6 " Zd _`e ViTVddZgV Z_ gR]fV R_U TR__`e SV T`_decfVU Rd R ScZSV `c aRj(`WW6 " Zd _`e Z_ gZ`]ReZ`_ `W Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh `c VeYZTR] deR_URcUd6 R_U " hZ]] _`e V^SRccRdd eYV T`^aR_j `c eYV Rdd`TZReV ZW afS]ZT]j UZdT]`dVU) JVV R]d` dfSdVTeZ`_ = SV]`h W`c T`_dZUVcReZ`_d cV]ReZ_X e` XZWed e` W`cVZX_ `WWZTZR]d R_U JVTeZ`_ MAA) 9 SV]`h W`c T`_dZUVcReZ`_d cV]ReZ_X e` XZWed e` X`gVc_^V_e V^a]`jVVd) 8( HTRTXeX]V >XUcb ?ZWed' WRg`cd' V_eVceRZ_^V_e `c `eYVc Z_UfTV^V_ed ^Rj _`e SV RTTVaeVU Sj Rdd`TZReVd `c ^V^SVcd `W eYVZc Z^^VUZReV WR^Z]ZVd Wc`^ R_j aVcd`_ `c `cXR_ZkReZ`_ eYRe U`Vd `c dVV\d e` U` SfdZ_Vdd hZeY' `c Zd R T`^aVeZe`c `W' eYV T`^aR_j& ViTVae Rd T`^^`_ T`fceVdZVd fdfR]]j Rdd`TZReVU hZeY Tfde`^Rcj SfdZ_Vdd acRTeZTVd) AW eYV XZWe Zd `W ^`cV eYR_ e`\V_ gR]fV' eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV ^fde Raac`gV Zed RTTVaeR_TV) 7] Tb_TRXP[[h bcaXRc bcP]SPaS P__[XTb fWT] bd__[XTab PaT X]e^[eTS( @U P VXUc d]Sd[h X]U[dT]RTb ^a \PZTb P] Pbb^RXPcT UTT[ ^Q[XVPcTS c^ i_Ph QPRZj cWT ^cWTa _Pach fXcW QdbX]Tbb& aTRTX_c ^U cWT VXUc Xb d]PRRT_cPQ[T( @c Xb ]TeTa PRRT_cPQ[T c^ PRRT_c P VXUc X] RPbW ^a RPbW T`dXeP[T]c( <eT] RPbW VXUcb ^U c^ZT] eP[dT \dbc QT STR[X]TS P]S aTcda]TS c^ cWT bT]STa( 9( K]UPXa 9^\_TcXcX^] 8]eY`fXY eYV WcVV V_eVcacZdV djdeV^ Zd SRdVU fa`_ T`^aVeZeZ`_' cf]Vd YRgV SVV_ Z^a`dVU deReZ_X hYRe TR_ R_U hYRe TR__`e SV U`_V Z_ R T`^aVeZeZgV V_gZc`_^V_e) KYV W`]]`hZ_X acRTeZTVd TR_ ]VRU e` ]ZRSZ]Zej W`c mf_WRZc T`^aVeZeZ`_n R_U dY`f]U SV Rg`ZUVU) KYVj RcV gZ`]ReZ`_d `W eYV ;`UV) Disparagement of Competitors. Ae Zd _`e Z]]VXR] e` a`Z_e `fe hVR\_VddVd Z_ R T`^aVeZe`cod dVcgZTV' ac`UfTe `c `aVcReZ`_6 Y`hVgVc' Rdd`TZReVd ^Rj _`e dacVRU WR]dV cf^`cd RS`fe T`^aVeZe`cd `c ^R\V ^ZdcVacVdV_eReZ`_d RS`fe eYVZc SfdZ_VddVd) >`c ViR^a]V' R_ Rdd`TZReV ^Rj _`e aRdd `_ R_VTU`eR] `c f_gVcZWZVU de`cZVd RS`fe R T`^aVeZe`cod ac`UfTed `c dVcgZTVd Rd eYV RSd`]feV ecfeY %V)X)' eYV deReV^V_e eYRe m`fc T`^aVeZe`cdo UZRX_`deZT eVdeZ_X ac`TVUfcVd YRgV a``c bfR]Zej T`_ec`]n&) Disrupting a Competitor’s Business. KYZd Z_T]fUVd ScZSZ_X R T`^aVeZe`cod V^a]`jVVd' a`dZ_X Rd ac`daVTeZgV Tfde`^Vcd `c fdZ_X UVTVaeZgV acRTeZTVd dfTY Rd V_eZTZ_X RhRj V^a]`jVVd Z_ `cUVc e` `SeRZ_ dVTcVed `c UVdec`j R T`^aVeZe`cod `cXR_ZkReZ`_) >`c ViR^a]V' Ze Zd _`e R gR]ZU W`c^ 4


 
`W m^Rc\Ve cVdVRcTYn e` gZdZe R T`^aVeZe`cod a]RTV `W SfdZ_Vdd a`dZ_X Rd R Tfde`^Vc) Misrepresentations of Price and Product) CZVd `c ^ZdcVacVdV_eReZ`_d RS`fe eYV _RefcV' bfR]Zej `c TYRcRTeVc `W eYV T`^aR_jod dVcgZTVd R_U ac`UfTed RcV S`eY Z]]VXR] R_U T`_ecRcj e` T`^aR_j a`]ZTj) 8_ Rdd`TZReV ^Rj `_]j UVdTcZSV `fc dVcgZTVd R_U ac`UfTed SRdVU `_ eYVZc U`Tf^V_eVU daVTZWZTReZ`_d' _`e SRdVU `_ R_VTU`eV `c YZd `c YVc SV]ZVW eYRe `fc daVTZWZTReZ`_d RcV e`` T`_dVcgReZgV) ;( 7]cXcadbc 9^]RTa]b >VUVcR] R_U deReV R_eZecfde ]Rhd RcV Z_eV_UVU e` acVdVcgV eYV WcVV V_eVcacZdV djdeV^ Sj V_dfcZ_X eYRe T`^aVeZeZ`_ Zd eYV acZ^Rcj cVXf]Re`c `W eYV VT`_`^j) =gVcj T`ca`cReV UVTZdZ`_ eYRe Z_g`]gVd Tfde`^Vcd' T`^aVeZe`cd' R_U SfdZ_Vdd a]R__Z_X hZeY cVdaVTe e` `feafe' dR]Vd R_U acZTZ_X cRZdVd R_eZecfde ZddfVd) ;`^a]ZR_TV hZeY eYV R_eZecfde ]Rhd Zd Z_ eYV afS]ZT Z_eVcVde' Z_ eYV Z_eVcVde `W eYV SfdZ_Vdd T`^^f_Zej Re ]RcXV' R_U Z_ `fc T`^aR_jod Z_eVcVde) >RZ]Z_X e` cVT`X_ZkV R_eZecfde cZd\ Zd T`de]j) 8_eZecfde ]ZeZXReZ`_ TR_ SV gVcj ViaV_dZgV R_U eZ^V(T`_df^Z_X) D`cV`gVc' gZ`]ReZ`_d `W eYV R_eZecfde ]Rhd TR_' R^`_X `eYVc eYZ_Xd' dfS[VTe j`f R_U eYV T`^aR_j e` eYV Z^a`dZeZ`_ `W Z_[f_TeZ`_d' ecVS]V UR^RXVd' R_U YVRgj WZ_Vd) ;cZ^Z_R] aV_R]eZVd ^Rj R]d` SV Z^a`dVU' R_U Z_UZgZUfR] Rdd`TZReVd TR_ cVTVZgV YVRgj WZ_Vd `c VgV_ SV Z^acZd`_VU) >`c eYZd cVRd`_' R_eZecfde T`^a]ZR_TV dY`f]U SV eR\V_ dVcZ`fd]j Re R]] ]VgV]d hZeYZ_ eYV T`^aR_j) 8 acZ^Rcj W`Tfd `W R_eZecfde ]Rhd Zd `_ UVR]Z_Xd SVehVV_ T`^aVeZe`cd) A_ R]] Z_eVcRTeZ`_d hZeY RTefR] `c a`eV_eZR] T`^aVeZe`cd R]] Rdd`TZReVd ^fde W`]]`h eYVdV cf]Vd5 " EVgVc RXcVV hZeY R T`^aVeZe`c `c R Xc`fa `W T`^aVeZe`cd e` TYRcXV eYV dR^V acZTVd `c e` fdV eYV dR^V acZTZ_X ^VeY`Ud' e` R]]`TReV dVcgZTVd' Tfde`^Vcd' acZgReV `c X`gVc_^V_eR] aRj`c T`_ecRTed `c eVccZe`cZVd R^`_X j`fcdV]gVd' e` S`jT`ee `c cVWfdV e` U` SfdZ_Vdd hZeY R ac`gZUVc' gV_U`c' aRj`c `c R_j `eYVc eYZcU aRcej' `c e` cVWcRZ_ Wc`^ eYV dR]V `c ^Rc\VeZ_X `W' `c ]Z^Ze eYV dfaa]j `W' aRceZTf]Rc ac`UfTed `c dVcgZTVd) " EVgVc UZdTfdd aRde' acVdV_e' `c WfefcV acZTVd' acZTZ_X a`]ZTZVd' Sf_U]Z_X' UZdT`f_ed `c R]]`hR_TVd' c`jR]eZVd' eVc^d `c T`_UZeZ`_d `W dR]V' T`ded' TY`ZTV `W Tfde`^Vcd' eVccZe`cZR] ^Rc\Ved' ac`UfTeZ`_ bf`eRd' R]]`TReZ`_ `W Tfde`^Vcd `c eVccZe`cZVd' `c SZUUZ_X `_ R [`S hZeY R T`^aVeZe`c) " 9V TRcVWf] `W j`fc T`_UfTe) 8_ mRXcVV^V_en eYRe gZ`]ReVd eYV R_eZecfde ]Rhd ^Rj SV _`e `_]j R hcZeeV_ `c `cR] RXcVV^V_e' Sfe R]d` R mXV_e]V^V_od RXcVV^V_en `c R eRTZe f_UVcdeR_UZ_X) JfTY R_ mRXcVV^V_en _VVU _`e SV Z_ hcZeZ_X) Ae TR_ SV Z_WVccVU Wc`^ T`_UfTe' UZdTfddZ`_d `c T`^^f_ZTReZ`_d `W R_j d`ce hZeY R cVacVdV_eReZgV `W R T`^aVeZe`c) " DR\V VgVcj `feafe R_U dR]Vd(cV]ReVU UVTZdZ`_ %acZTZ_X' g`]f^V' VeT)& Z_UVaV_UV_e]j' Z_ ]ZXYe `W T`ded R_U ^Rc\Ve T`_UZeZ`_d R_U T`^aVeZeZgV acZTVd) ,+


 
" ;RcVWf]]j ^`_Ze`c ecRUV Rdd`TZReZ`_ RTeZgZej) KYVdV W`cf^d WcVbfV_e]j TcVReV R_ `aa`cef_Zej W`c T`^aVeZe`cd e` V_XRXV Z_ R_eZecfde gZ`]ReZ`_d) 8_`eYVc W`Tfd `W R_eZecfde ]Rh Zd Y`h R T`^aR_j UVR]d hZeY Tfde`^Vcd' dfaa]ZVcd' T`_ecRTe`cd R_U `eYVc eYZcU aRceZVd) KYV W`]]`hZ_X acRTeZTVd T`f]U cRZdV ZddfVd' R_U Rdd`TZReVd dY`f]U R]hRjd T`_df]e hZeY eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV SVW`cV U`Z_X R_j `W eYV W`]]`hZ_X5 " IVWfdV e` dV]] e` R_j Tfde`^Vcd `c ac`daVTeZgV Tfde`^Vc6 " =_eVc Z_e` R_j _Vh UZdecZSfeZ`_ `c dfaa]j RXcVV^V_e hYZTY UZWWVcd Z_ R_j cVdaVTe Wc`^ eY`dV acVgZ`fd]j Raac`gVU6 " ;`_UZeZ`_ R dR]V `_ eYV Tfde`^Vcod afcTYRdZ_X R_`eYVc ac`UfTe `c dVcgZTV' `c `_ _`e afcTYRdZ_X eYV ac`UfTe `W R T`^aVeZe`c6 " 8XcVV hZeY R Tfde`^Vc `_ R ^Z_Z^f^ `c ^RiZ^f^ cVdR]V acZTV `W `fc ac`UfTed6 " A^a`dV cVdecZTeZ`_d `_ eYV XV`XcRaYZT RcVR e` hYZTY `fc Tfde`^Vcd ^Rj cVdV]] `fc ac`UfTed6 " IVbfZcV R dfaa]ZVc e` afcTYRdV ac`UfTed Wc`^ eYV T`^aR_j Rd R T`_UZeZ`_ `W afcTYRdZ_X ac`UfTed Wc`^ eYRe dfaa]ZVc6 " =_eVc Z_e` R_ ViT]fdZgV UVR]Z_X RccR_XV^V_e hZeY R dfaa]ZVc `c Tfde`^Vc6 `c " FWWVc UZWWVcV_e acZTVd' eVc^d' dVcgZTVd `c R]]`hR_TVd e` UZWWVcV_e Tfde`^Vcd hY` T`^aVeV `c hY`dV Tfde`^Vcd T`^aVeV Z_ eYV UZdecZSfeZ`_ `W T`^^`UZeZVd) AW `fc T`^aR_j YRd R U`^Z_R_e `c a`eV_eZR]]j U`^Z_R_e a`dZeZ`_ hZeY cVdaVTe e` R aRceZTf]Rc ac`UfTe `c ^Rc\Ve' VdaVTZR]]j cZX`c`fd deR_URcUd `W T`_UfTe ^fde SV W`]]`hVU) A_ eYVdV TZcTf^deR_TVd' R]] Rdd`TZReVd dY`f]U5 " ;`_df]e hZeY eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV SVW`cV dV]]Z_X Re f_cVRd`_RS]j ]`h acZTVd `c V_XRXZ_X Z_ R_j Sf_U]Z_X acRTeZTVd6 R_U " BVVa eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV Wf]]j Z_W`c^VU `W T`^aVeZeZgV decReVXZVd R_U T`_UZeZ`_d Z_ R_j RcVRd hYVcV eYV T`^aR_j ^Rj YRgV R dZX_ZWZTR_e ^Rc\Ve a`dZeZ`_) >Z_R]]j' R]hRjd Z^^VUZReV]j Z_W`c^ eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV ZW ]`TR]' deReV `c WVUVcR] ]Rh V_W`cTV^V_e `WWZTZR]d cVbfVde Z_W`c^ReZ`_ Wc`^ eYV T`^aR_j T`_TVc_Z_X Zed `aVcReZ`_d) ,,


 
<( K]UPXa FaPRcXRTb X] @]cTa]PcX^]P[ 8dbX]Tbb L_UVc eYV >`cVZX_ ;`ccfae GcRTeZTVd 8Te %m>;G8n&' Rdd`TZReVd `W eYV T`^aR_j RcV ac`YZSZeVU Wc`^ ^R\Z_X TVceRZ_ XZWed e` W`cVZX_ `WWZTZR]d) m>`cVZX_ `WWZTZR]dn Z_T]fUV _`e `_]j aVcd`_d RTeZ_X Z_ R_ `WWZTZR] TRaRTZej `_ SVYR]W `W R W`cVZX_ X`gVc_^V_e' RXV_Tj' UVaRce^V_e `c Z_decf^V_eR]Zej' Sfe R]d` cVacVdV_eReZgVd `W Z_eVc_ReZ`_R] `cXR_ZkReZ`_d' W`cVZX_ a`]ZeZTR] aRceZVd R_U TR_UZUReVd W`c W`cVZX_ afS]ZT `WWZTV) KYV XZWe Zd mT`ccfaen f_UVc eYV >;G8 ZW Ze Zd ^RUV W`c eYV afca`dV `W5 " Z_W]fV_TZ_X R_j RTe `c UVTZdZ`_ `W R W`cVZX_ `WWZTZR] Z_ YZd `WWZTZR] TRaRTZej6 " Z_UfTZ_X R W`cVZX_ `WWZTZR] e` U` `c `^Ze e` U` R_j RTe Z_ gZ`]ReZ`_ `W YZd ]RhWf] Ufej6 " Z_UfTZ_X R W`cVZX_ `WWZTZR] e` fdV YZd a`dZeZ`_ e` RWWVTe R_j UVTZdZ`_ `W eYV X`gVc_^V_e6 `c " Z_UfTZ_X R W`cVZX_ `WWZTZR] e` dVTfcV R_j mZ^ac`aVc RUgR_eRXV)n 8 XZWe Zd deZ]] mT`ccfaen VgV_ hYV_ aRZU eYc`fXY R_ Z_eVc^VUZRcj) 8_j Rdd`TZReV hY` YRd R_j bfVdeZ`_d hYRed`VgVc Rd e` hYVeYVc R aRceZTf]Rc XZWe ^ZXYe SV mT`ccfaen f_UVc eYV >;G8' a]VRdV T`_eRTe eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_j ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) L@@( >EL<HDC<DJ H<B7J@EDI 8dd`TZReVd ^fde RUYVcV e` eYV YZXYVde deR_URcUd `W VeYZTR] T`_UfTe Z_ R]] cV]ReZ`_dYZad hZeY X`gVc_^V_e V^a]`jVVd R_U ^fde _`e Z^ac`aVc]j ReeV^ae e` Z_W]fV_TV eYV RTeZ`_d `W R_j afS]ZT `WWZTZR]) 7( >^eTa]\T]c Fa^RdaT\T]c P]S =d]SX]V KYV L)J) X`gVc_^V_e' X`gVc_^V_ed `W `eYVc T`f_ecZVd R_U ^R_j deReV' cVXZ`_R] R_U ]`TR] X`gVc_^V_ed YRgV RU`aeVU T`^acVYV_dZgV ]Rhd R_U cVXf]ReZ`_d X`gVc_Z_X eYV afcTYRdV `W ac`UfTed Wc`^ acZgReV T`_ecRTe`cd `c eYV ac`gZdZ`_ `W Wf_Ud e` eYV acZgReV dVTe`c W`c cVdVRcTY R_U UVgV]`a^V_e) KYVdV ]Rhd R_U cVXf]ReZ`_d RcV Z_eV_UVU e` RddfcV eYRe X`gVc_^V_eR] V_eZeZVd cVTVZgV acZTZ_X' eVc^d' R_U*`c T`_UZeZ`_d VbfZgR]V_e e` eY`dV XcR_eVU e` eYV T`^aR_jod ^`de WRg`cVU T`^^VcTZR] T`f_eVcaRceZVd R_U eYRe eYVcV Zd Wf]] R_U `aV_ T`^aVeZeZ`_ Z_ T`_ecRTeZ_X) NYV_ dV]]Z_X ac`UfTed `c dVcgZTVd e`' `c dVV\Z_X Wf_UZ_X Wc`^' X`gVc_^V_e RXV_TZVd' eYV T`^aR_j Zd RTT`f_eRS]V W`c T`^a]jZ_X hZeY R]] Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rhd' cVXf]ReZ`_d' R_U cVbfZcV^V_ed) ;VceZWZTReZ`_d e`' R_U T`_ecRTed hZeY' X`gVc_^V_e RXV_TZVd RcV e` SV dZX_VU Sj R T`^aR_j Rdd`TZReV RfeY`cZkVU Sj eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd e` dZX_ dfTY U`Tf^V_ed' SRdVU fa`_ \_`h]VUXV eYRe R]] cVbfZcV^V_ed YRgV SVV_ Wf]]j dReZdWZVU) 8( FPh\T]cb c^ EUUXRXP[b ,-


 
GRj^V_ed `c XZWed dYR]] _`e SV ^RUV UZcVTe]j `c Z_UZcVTe]j e` R_j X`gVc_^V_e `WWZTZR] `c Rdd`TZReV ZW eYV XZWe `c aRj^V_e Zd Z]]VXR] f_UVc eYV ]Rhd `W eYV T`f_ecj YRgZ_X [fcZdUZTeZ`_ `gVc eYV ecR_dRTeZ`_' `c ZW Ze Zd W`c eYV afca`dV `W Z_W]fV_TZ_X `c Z_UfTZ_X eYV cVTZaZV_e e` U`' `c `^Ze e` U`' R_j RTe Z_ gZ`]ReZ`_ `W YZd `c YVc ]RhWf] Ufej) L_UVc _` TZcTf^deR_TVd dY`f]U XZWed SV XZgV_ e` R_j X`gVc_^V_e V^a]`jVVd) 9( F^[XcXRP[ 9^]caXQdcX^]b ;`^aR_j Wf_Ud' ac`aVcej `c dVcgZTVd ^Rj _`e SV T`_ecZSfeVU e` R_j a`]ZeZTR] aRcej `c T`^^ZeeVV' `c e` R_j TR_UZUReV W`c `c Y`]UVc `W R_j `WWZTV `W R_j X`gVc_^V_e) KYZd a`]ZTj U`Vd _`e acVT]fUV' hYVcV ]RhWf]' T`^aR_j ViaV_UZefcVd e` dfaa`ce `c `aa`dV afS]ZT cVWVcV_Uf^ `c dVaRcReV SR]]`e ZddfVd' `c' hYVcV ]RhWf] R_U hYV_ cVgZVhVU R_U Raac`gVU Z_ RUgR_TV Sj eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' eYV W`c^ReZ`_ R_U `aVcReZ`_ `W R a`]ZeZTR] RTeZ`_ T`^^ZeeVV) L@@@( 9ECFB@7D9< M@J? B7MI& HKB<I 7D; H<>KB7J@EDI 7( @]bXSTa JaPSX]V F^[XRh KYV T`^aR_j ViacVdd]j W`cSZUd R_j Rdd`TZReV Wc`^ ecRUZ_X `_ ^ReVcZR] _`_(afS]ZT Z_W`c^ReZ`_ `c T`^^f_ZTReZ_X ^ReVcZR] _`_(afS]ZT Z_W`c^ReZ`_ e` `eYVcd Z_ gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ]Rh) KYZd T`_UfTe Zd WcVbfV_e]j cVWVccVU e` Rd mZ_dZUVc ecRUZ_X)n KYZd a`]ZTj Raa]ZVd e` VgVcj Rdd`TZReV `W eYV T`^aR_j R_U VieV_Ud e` RTeZgZeZVd S`eY hZeYZ_ R_U `fedZUV eYVZc UfeZVd e` eYV T`^aR_j' Z_T]fUZ_X ecRUZ_X W`c R aVcd`_R] RTT`f_e) KYV T`_TVae `W hY` Zd R_ mZ_dZUVcn Zd Sc`RU) Ae Z_T]fUVd `WWZTVcd' UZcVTe`cd R_U V^a]`jVVd `W R T`^aR_j) A_ RUUZeZ`_' R aVcd`_ TR_ SV R meV^a`cRcj Z_dZUVcn ZW YV `c dYV V_eVcd Z_e` R daVTZR] T`_WZUV_eZR] cV]ReZ`_dYZa Z_ eYV T`_UfTe `W R T`^aR_jod RWWRZcd R_U Rd R cVdf]e Zd XZgV_ RTTVdd e` Z_W`c^ReZ`_ d`]V]j W`c eYV T`^aR_jod afca`dV) 8 eV^a`cRcj Z_dZUVc TR_ Z_T]fUV' R^`_X `eYVcd' R T`^aR_jod Z_gVde^V_e RUgZd`cd' RXV_ed' Ree`c_Vjd' RTT`f_eR_ed R_U ]V_UZ_X Z_deZefeZ`_d' Rd hV]] Rd eYV V^a]`jVVd `W dfTY `cXR_ZkReZ`_d) 8_ Rdd`TZReV ^Rj R]d` SVT`^V R eV^a`cRcj Z_dZUVc `W another company hZeY hYZTY `fc T`^aR_j YRd R T`_ecRTefR] `c `eYVc cV]ReZ`_dYZa) KcRUZ_X `_ Z_dZUV Z_W`c^ReZ`_ Zd _`e R SRdZd W`c ]ZRSZ]Zej f_]Vdd eYV Z_W`c^ReZ`_ Zd ^ReVcZR]) KYZd Zd Z_W`c^ReZ`_ eYRe R cVRd`_RS]V Z_gVde`c h`f]U T`_dZUVc Z^a`ceR_e Z_ ^R\Z_X YZd `c YVc Z_gVde^V_e UVTZdZ`_d' `c Z_W`c^ReZ`_ eYRe Zd ]Z\V]j e` YRgV R dZX_ZWZTR_e VWWVTe `_ eYV acZTV `W R T`^aR_jod dVTfcZeZVd) A_W`c^ReZ`_ Zd _`_(afS]ZT f_eZ] Ze YRd SVV_ VWWVTeZgV]j T`^^f_ZTReVU e` eYV ^Rc\Vea]RTV) KR_XZS]V VgZUV_TV `W dfTY UZddV^Z_ReZ`_ Zd eYV SVde Z_UZTReZ`_ eYRe eYV Z_W`c^ReZ`_ Zd afS]ZT) >`c ViR^a]V' Z_W`c^ReZ`_ W`f_U Z_ R cVa`ce WZ]VU hZeY eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_ `c RaaVRcZ_X Z_ R _ReZ`_R] _VhdaRaVc h`f]U SV T`_dZUVcVU afS]ZT) =RTY Rdd`TZReV dY`f]U SV WR^Z]ZRc hZeY R_U RSZUV Sj eYV T`^aR_jod A_dZUVc KcRUZ_X G`]ZTj) 8 T`aj `W eYZd a`]ZTj Zd XZgV_ e` R]] _Vh Rdd`TZReVd `W eYV T`^aR_j R_U Zd RgRZ]RS]V Wc`^ eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc) ,.


 
8( <`dP[ <\_[^h\T]c E__^acd]Xch KYV T`^aR_j ^R\Vd V^a]`j^V_e(cV]ReVU UVTZdZ`_d hZeY`fe cVXRcU e` R aVcd`_od cRTV' T`]`c' cV]ZXZ`fd TcVVU' RXV' dVi' dVifR] `cZV_eReZ`_' ^RcZeR] deRefd' _ReZ`_R] `cZXZ_' R_TVdecj' acVdV_e `c aRde YZde`cj `W ^V_eR] UZd`cUVc' ^V_eR] cVeRcUReZ`_' ]VRc_Z_X UZdRSZ]Zej `c aYjdZTR] UZdRSZ]Zej' Z_T]fUZ_X' Sfe _`e ]Z^ZeVU e`' S]Z_U_Vdd R_U XV_VeZT acVUZda`dZeZ`_' `c R_j `eYVc WRTe`c f_cV]ReVU e` R aVcd`_od RSZ]Zej e` aVcW`c^ eYV aVcd`_od [`S) m=^a]`j^V_e UVTZdZ`_dn XV_VcR]]j ^VR_ UVTZdZ`_d cV]ReZ_X e` YZcZ_X' cVTcfZeZ_X' ecRZ_Z_X' ac`^`eZ`_d R_U T`^aV_dReZ`_' Sfe eYV eVc^ ^Rj V_T`^aRdd `eYVc V^a]`j^V_e RTeZ`_d Rd hV]]) KYV T`^aR_j V_T`fcRXVd Zed Rdd`TZReVd e` ScZ_X R_j ac`S]V^' T`^a]RZ_e `c T`_TVc_ cVXRcUZ_X R_j R]]VXVU V^a]`j^V_e UZdTcZ^Z_ReZ`_ e` eYV ReeV_eZ`_ `W eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_j ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV( 8dd`TZReVd hY` YRgV T`_TVc_d cVXRcUZ_X T`_UfTe eYVj SV]ZVgV Zd UZdTcZ^Z_Re`cj dY`f]U R]d` WVV] WcVV e` ^R\V R_j dfTY cVa`ced e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc' R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' `c eYV @`e]Z_V) 9( ITgdP[ ?PaPbb\T]c F^[XRh KYV T`^aR_j Zd T`^^ZeeVU e` ^RZ_eRZ_Z_X R T`]]VXZR] h`c\ V_gZc`_^V_e Z_ hYZTY R]] Z_UZgZUfR]d RcV ecVReVU hZeY cVdaVTe R_U UZX_Zej R_U hYZTY Zd WcVV `W dVifR] YRcRdd^V_e) A_ \VVaZ_X hZeY eYZd T`^^Ze^V_e' eYV T`^aR_j hZ]] _`e e`]VcReV dVifR] YRcRdd^V_e `W Rdd`TZReVd Sj R_j`_V' Z_T]fUZ_X R_j dfaVcgZd`c' T`(h`c\Vc' gV_U`c' T]ZV_e `c Tfde`^Vc' hYVeYVc Z_ eYV h`c\a]RTV' Re RddZX_^V_ed `fedZUV eYV h`c\a]RTV' Re T`^aR_j(da`_d`cVU d`TZR] Wf_TeZ`_d `c V]dVhYVcV) ;( ?TP[cW& IPUTch " <]eXa^]\T]c BPfb @VR]eY' dRWVej' R_U V_gZc`_^V_eR] cVda`_dZSZ]ZeZVd RcV Wf_UR^V_eR] e` eYV T`^aR_jod gR]fVd) 8dd`TZReVd RcV cVda`_dZS]V W`c V_dfcZ_X eYRe eYV T`^aR_j T`^a]ZVd hZeY R]] ac`gZdZ`_d `W eYV YVR]eY' dRWVej' R_U V_gZc`_^V_eR] ]Rhd `W eYV L_ZeVU JeReVd R_U `W `eYVc T`f_ecZVd hYVcV eYV T`^aR_j U`Vd SfdZ_Vdd) KYV aV_R]eZVd eYRe TR_ SV Z^a`dVU RXRZ_de eYV T`^aR_j R_U Zed Rdd`TZReVd W`c WRZ]fcV e` T`^a]j hZeY YVR]eY' dRWVej' R_U V_gZc`_^V_eR] ]Rhd TR_ SV dfSdeR_eZR]' R_U Z_T]fUV Z^acZd`_^V_e R_U WZ_Vd) @N( GK<IJ@EDI KD;<H J?< 9E;< 7D; M7@L<H FHE9<;KH<I 8dd`TZReVd RcV V_T`fcRXVU e` T`_df]e hZeY eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc R_U ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV RS`fe R_j f_TVceRZ_ej `c bfVdeZ`_d eYVj ^Rj YRgV f_UVc eYV ;`UV) AW R_j dZefReZ`_ dY`f]U RcZdV hYVcV R T`fcdV `W RTeZ`_ h`f]U ]Z\V]j cVdf]e Z_ R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV Sfe W`c hYZTY eYV Rdd`TZReV eYZ_\d eYRe R gR]ZU cVRd`_ W`c eYV T`fcdV `W RTeZ`_ ViZded' eYV Rdd`TZReV dY`f]U T`_eRTe eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV e` `SeRZ_ R hRZgVc _aX^a c^ cWT cX\T cWT PRcX^] Xb cPZT]( D^ fPXeTab fX[[ QT VaP]cTS PUcTa cWT UPRc U^a PRcX^]b P[aTPSh cPZT]( =iTVae Rd _`eVU SV]`h' eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV ,/


 
hZ]] cVgZVh R]] eYV WRTed dfcc`f_UZ_X eYV ac`a`dVU T`fcdV `W RTeZ`_ R_U hZ]] UVeVc^Z_V hYVeYVc R hRZgVc Wc`^ R_j a`]ZTj Z_ eYV ;`UV dY`f]U SV XcR_eVU) Waiver Procedures for Executive Officers and Directors. NRZgVc cVbfVded Sj R_ ViVTfeZgV `WWZTVc `c ^V^SVc `W eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd dYR]] SV cVWVccVU Sj eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' hZeY Zed cVT`^^V_UReZ`_' e` eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `c R T`^^ZeeVV eYVcV`W W`c T`_dZUVcReZ`_) AW VZeYVc %Z& R ^R[`cZej `W eYV Z_UVaV_UV_e UZcVTe`cd `_ eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd' `c %ZZ& R T`^^ZeeVV T`^acZdVU d`]V]j `W Z_UVaV_UV_e UZcVTe`cd RXcVVd eYRe eYV hRZgVc dY`f]U SV XcR_eVU' Ze hZ]] SV XcR_eVU) KYV T`^aR_j hZ]] UZdT]`dV eYV _RefcV R_U cVRd`_d W`c eYV hRZgVc `_ R >`c^ 3(B e` SV WZ]VU hZeY eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_ hZeYZ_ W`fc SfdZ_Vdd URjd `c Rd `eYVchZdV aVc^ZeeVU Sj eYV cf]Vd `W eYV JVTfcZeZVd R_U =iTYR_XV ;`^^ZddZ`_ R_U KYV ERdURb Je`T\ DRc\Ve( AW eYV 9`RcU UV_ZVd eYV cVbfVde W`c R hRZgVc' eYV hRZgVc hZ]] _`e SV XcR_eVU R_U eYV Rdd`TZReV ^Rj _`e afcdfV eYV Z_eV_UVU T`fcdV `W RTeZ`_) @c Xb cWT R^\_P]hkb _^[XRh ^][h c^ VaP]c fPXeTab Ua^\ cWT 9^ST X] [X\XcTS P]S TgcaP^aSX]Pah RXaRd\bcP]RTb( N( =H<GK<DJBO 7IA<; GK<IJ@EDI #=7GkI$ H<>7H;@D> H<FEHJ@D> L@EB7J@EDI KD;<H J?< 9E;<& M?@IJB<8BEM<H FEB@9O 7D; ?EJB@D< KYV W`]]`hZ_X bfVdeZ`_d R_U R_dhVcd RUUcVdd VRTY Rdd`TZReVod `S]ZXReZ`_ e` T`^a]j hZeY eYV ;`UV) KYV T`^aR_j YRd ReeV^aeVU e` UVdZX_ ac`TVUfcVd eYRe V_dfcV ^RiZ^f^ T`_WZUV_eZR]Zej R_U' ^`de Z^a`ceR_e]j' WcVVU`^ Wc`^ eYV WVRc `W cVeR]ZReZ`_ W`c T`^a]jZ_X hZeY R_U cVa`ceZ_X gZ`]ReZ`_d f_UVc eYV ;`UV) G3 ;^ @ WPeT P Sdch c^ aT_^ac eX^[PcX^]b d]STa cWT 9^ST5 73 PVd' aRceZTZaReZ`_ Z_ eYV ;`UV R_U Zed T`^a]ZR_TV ac`XcR^ Zd ^R_URe`cj) P`f ^fde Z^^VUZReV]j cVa`ce R_j dfdaVTeVU `c RTefR] gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV e` eYV @`e]Z_V' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV) KYV T`^aR_j hZ]] \VVa cVa`ced T`_WZUV_eZR] e` eYV Wf]]Vde VieV_e cVbfZcVU Sj Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh) >RZ]fcV e` cVa`ce dfdaVTeVU `c RTefR] gZ`]ReZ`_d Zd ZedV]W R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV R_U ^Rj dfS[VTe j`f e` UZdTZa]Z_Rcj RTeZ`_' fa e` R_U Z_T]fUZ_X eVc^Z_ReZ`_ `W V^a]`j^V_e `c ]VXR] RTeZ`_) G3 @k\ PUaPXS ^U QTX]V UXaTS U^a aPXbX]V `dTbcX^]b ^a aT_^acX]V eX^[PcX^]b d]STa cWT 9^ST( MX[[ @ QT aXbZX]V \h Y^Q XU @ S^5 73 KYV ;`UV T`_eRZ_d R T]VRc R_eZ(cVeR]ZReZ`_ a]VUXV' ^VR_Z_X eYRe ZW j`f Z_ X``U WRZeY cVa`ce R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV Sj eYV T`^aR_j' `c Zed RXV_ed RTeZ_X `_ SVYR]W `W eYV T`^aR_j' e` eYV @`e]Z_V' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_`eYVc ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' eYV T`^aR_j hZ]] f_UVceR\V e` ac`eVTe j`f Wc`^ SVZ_X WZcVU' UV^`eVU' cVacZ^R_UVU `c `eYVchZdV YRc^VU W`c cVa`ceZ_X eYV gZ`]ReZ`_' VgV_ ZW eYV gZ`]ReZ`_ Z_g`]gVd j`f' j`fc dfaVcgZd`c' `c dV_Z`c ^R_RXV^V_e `W eYV T`^aR_j) E`eV' Y`hVgVc' eYRe hYZ]V j`f hZ]] _`e SV UZdTZa]Z_VU W`c cVa`ceZ_X R gZ`]ReZ`_' j`f ^Rj SV dfS[VTe e` UZdTZa]Z_V hZeY cVdaVTe e` eYV f_UVc]jZ_X T`_UfTe `c gZ`]ReZ`_) P`f RcV V_eZe]VU e` ^R\V eYV cVa`ce `_ R T`_WZUV_eZR] R_U R_`_j^`fd SRdZd) K` eYV VieV_e R_ ,0


 
Z_gVdeZXReZ`_ ^fde SV Z_ZeZReVU' eYV T`^aR_j hZ]] \VVa T`_WZUV_eZR] R_j cVa`ce j`f ^R\V e` eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_`eYVc ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV e` eYV VieV_e cVbfZcVU Sj Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh) A_ RUUZeZ`_' ZW j`f Z_ X``U WRZeY cVa`ce R dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ f_UVc eYV ;`UV hYZTY j`f cVRd`_RS]j SV]ZVgV T`_deZefeVd R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W R WVUVcR] deRefeV Sj eYV T`^aR_j' `c Zed RXV_ed RTeZ_X `_ SVYR]W `W eYV T`^aR_j' e` R WVUVcR] cVXf]Re`cj `c ]Rh V_W`cTV^V_e RXV_Tj' j`f ^Rj _`e SV cVacZ^R_UVU' UZdTYRcXVU' UV^`eVU' dfdaV_UVU' eYcVReV_VU' YRcRddVU `c Z_ R_j ^R__Vc UZdTcZ^Z_ReVU RXRZ_de Z_ eYV eVc^d R_U T`_UZeZ`_d `W j`fc V^a]`j^V_e W`c cVa`ceZ_X eYV dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_' cVXRcU]Vdd `W hYVeYVc eYV dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ Z_g`]gVd j`f' j`fc dfaVcgZd`c `c dV_Z`c ^R_RXV^V_e `W eYV T`^aR_j) 8dd`TZReVd RcV V_T`fcRXVU e` afcdfV R]] Z_eVc_R] cVa`ceZ_X TYR__V]d eYc`fXY T`^a]VeZ`_ R_U cVRd`_RS]j RhRZe R_U T`_dZUVc eYV cVdf]ed `W R]] Z_eVc_R] Z_gVdeZXReZ`_d acZ`c e` cVa`ceZ_X ^ReeVcd `fedZUV `W eYV T`^aR_j) NV YRgV Z_deZefeVU eYV ac`TVUfcVd UVdTcZSVU Z_ eYZd ;`UV' Z_T]fUZ_X ac`TVUfcVd e` ^R\V R_`_j^`fd dfS^ZddZ`_d %R W`c^ `W Z_eVc_R] cVa`ce&' e` WRTZ]ZeReV eYV fdV `W Z_eVc_R] Z_gVdeZXReZ`_d) A_UZgZUfR]d dY`f]U R]d` T`_dZUVc ]VRgZ_X' Sfe RcV _`e cVbfZcVU e` ]VRgV' eYVZc _R^V `c R T`_eRTe _f^SVc hYV_ dfS^ZeeZ_X R cVa`ce) JfTY Z_W`c^ReZ`_ ^Rj WRTZ]ZeReV R ^`cV eY`c`fXY R_U VWWZTZV_e Z_gVdeZXReZ`_) KYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc hZ]] decZgV e` ^RZ_eRZ_ eYV Z_eVXcZej R_U T`_WZUV_eZR]Zej `W R]] T`^a]ZR_TV(cV]ReVU T`^^f_ZTReZ`_d) @`hVgVc' Z_ TVceRZ_ TZcTf^deR_TVd' eYV ZUV_eZej `W eYV aVcd`_ cVa`ceZ_X eYV ZddfV ^Rj SVT`^V \_`h_ `c ^Rj _VVU e` SV cVgVR]VU' aRceZTf]Rc]j ZW WVUVcR] `c deReV V_W`cTV^V_e RfeY`cZeZVd SVT`^V Z_g`]gVU Z_ eYV Z_gVdeZXReZ`_) KYV T`^aR_j TR__`e XfRcR_eVV T`_WZUV_eZR]Zej hYV_ ^ReVcZR] VgZUV_TV `W R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ]Rh Zd UZdT]`dVU `c ZW eYV aVcd`_ Zd ZUV_eZWZVU UfcZ_X eYV _`c^R] T`fcdV `W R_ Z_gVdeZXReZ`_) G3 ?^f PaT bdb_TRcTS eX^[PcX^]b X]eTbcXVPcTS d]STa cWT 9^ST5 73 NYV_ R dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_ Zd cVa`ceVU e` eYV @`e]Z_V' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV hZ]] XReYVc Z_W`c^ReZ`_ RS`fe eYV R]]VXReZ`_ Sj Z_eVcgZVhZ_X eYV Rdd`TZReV cVa`ceZ_X eYV dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_' eYV Rdd`TZReV hY` Zd RTTfdVU `W eYV gZ`]ReZ`_ R_U*`c R_j T`(h`c\Vcd `c Rdd`TZReVd `W eYV RTTfdVU Rdd`TZReVd e` UVeVc^Z_V ZW R WRTefR] SRdZd W`c eYV R]]VXReZ`_ ViZded) KYV cVa`ceZ_X Rdd`TZReVod Z^^VUZReV dfaVcgZd`c hZ]] _`e SV Z_g`]gVU Z_ eYV Z_gVdeZXReZ`_ ZW eYV cVa`ceVU gZ`]ReZ`_ Z_g`]gVU eYRe dfaVcgZd`c) KYV T`^aR_j hZ]] \VVa eYV ZUV_eZej `W eYV cVa`ceZ_X Rdd`TZReV T`_WZUV_eZR] e` eYV Wf]]Vde VieV_e cVbfZcVU Sj Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh) AW eYV cVa`ce Zd _`e dfSdeR_eZReVU' eYV cVa`ceZ_X Rdd`TZReV hZ]] SV Z_W`c^VU R_U Re eYRe eZ^V hZ]] SV Rd\VU W`c R_j RUUZeZ`_R] Z_W`c^ReZ`_ _`e acVgZ`fd]j T`^^f_ZTReVU) AW eYVcV Zd _` RUUZeZ`_R] Z_W`c^ReZ`_' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc hZ]] T]`dV eYV ^ReeVc Rd f_dfSdeR_eZReVU) AW eYV R]]VXReZ`_ Zd dfSdeR_eZReVU' eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV hZ]] ^R\V R [fUX^V_e Rd e` eYV UVXcVV `W dVgVcZej `W eYV gZ`]ReZ`_ R_U eYV Raac`acZReV UZdTZa]Z_Rcj cVda`_dV) A_ ^`cV dVgVcV ,1


 
TRdVd' eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV hZ]] ^R\V R cVT`^^V_UReZ`_ e` eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `W eYV T`^aR_j W`c Zed Raac`gR]) KYV 9`RcUod UVTZdZ`_ Rd e` UZdTZa]Z_Rcj R_U T`ccVTeZgV RTeZ`_ hZ]] SV WZ_R]) A_ eYV TRdV `W ]Vdd dVgVcV gZ`]ReZ`_d' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc ^Rj cVWVc eYV gZ`]ReZ`_ e` eYV Z_UZgZUfR]od dfaVcgZd`c' eYV @f^R_ IVd`fcTVd <VaRce^V_e' eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c R_j ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV W`c Raac`acZReV UZdTZa]Z_Rcj RTeZ`_) KYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV dYR]] ac`gZUV R df^^Rcj `W R]] ^ReeVcd T`_dZUVcVU f_UVc eYV ;`UV e` eYV 9`RcU `W <ZcVTe`cd `c R T`^^ZeeVV eYVcV`W Re VRTY cVXf]Rc ^VVeZ_X eYVcV`W' `c d``_Vc ZW hRccR_eVU Sj eYV dVgVcZej `W eYV ^ReeVc) G3 ;^ @ WPeT c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] P]h X]eTbcXVPcX^] d]STa cWT 9^ST5 73 P`fc Wf]] T``aVcReZ`_ hZeY R_j aV_UZ_X Z_gVdeZXReZ`_ f_UVc eYV ;`UV Zd R T`_UZeZ`_ `W j`fc T`_eZ_fVU cV]ReZ`_dYZa hZeY eYV T`^aR_j) KYV cVWfdR] e` T``aVcReV Wf]]j hZeY R_j Z_gVdeZXReZ`_ Zd R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV R_U Xc`f_Ud W`c UZdTZa]Z_V' fa e` R_U Z_T]fUZ_X eVc^Z_ReZ`_) G3 MWPc PaT cWT R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U eX^[PcX]V cWT 9^ST5 73 8d Via]RZ_VU RS`gV' Rdd`TZReVd hY` gZ`]ReV eYV ;`UV ^Rj SV dfS[VTe e` UZdTZa]Z_V' fa e` R_U Z_T]fUZ_X eVc^Z_ReZ`_ `W V^a]`j^V_e) 8dd`TZReVd hY` gZ`]ReV eYV ;`UV ^Rj dZ^f]eR_V`fd]j gZ`]ReV WVUVcR]' deReV' ]`TR] `c W`cVZX_ ]Rhd' cVXf]ReZ`_d `c a`]ZTZVd) JfTY Rdd`TZReVd ^Rj SV dfS[VTe e` ac`dVTfeZ`_' Z^acZd`_^V_e R_U WZ_Vd' R_U ^Rj SV cVbfZcVU e` ^R\V cVZ^SfcdV^V_e e` eYV T`^aR_j' eYV X`gVc_^V_e `c R_j `eYVc aVcd`_ W`c ]`ddVd cVdf]eZ_X Wc`^ eYV gZ`]ReZ`_) KYVj ^Rj SV dfS[VTe e` af_ZeZgV `c ecVS]V UR^RXVd UVaV_UZ_X `_ eYV dVgVcZej `W eYV gZ`]ReZ`_ R_U Raa]ZTRS]V ]Rh) G3 MWPc XU @ WPeT `dTbcX^]b d]STa cWT 9^ST ^a fP]c c^ ^QcPX] P fPXeTa d]STa P]h _a^eXbX^] ^U cWT 9^ST5 73 KYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc R_U R_j ^V^SVc `W eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV TR_ YV]a R_dhVc bfVdeZ`_d j`f ^Rj YRgV f_UVc eYV ;`UV) GRceZTf]Rc]j UZWWZTf]e bfVdeZ`_d hZ]] SV R_dhVcVU hZeY Z_afe Wc`^ eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV Rd R hY`]V) A_ RUUZeZ`_' JVTeZ`_ AO `W eYV ;`UV ac`gZUVd Z_W`c^ReZ`_ `_ Y`h j`f ^Rj `SeRZ_ R hRZgVc Wc`^ eYV ;`UV6 hRZgVcd hZ]] SV XcR_eVU `_]j Z_ gVcj ]Z^ZeVU TZcTf^deR_TVd) P`f dY`f]U _VgVc afcdfV R T`fcdV `W RTeZ`_ eYRe Zd f_T]VRc f_UVc eYV ;`UV hZeY`fe WZcde T`_df]eZ_X eYV ;`ca`cReV ;`^a]ZR_TV FWWZTVc `c eYV ;`^a]ZR_TV ;`^^ZeeVV' R_U ZW _VTVddRcj' `SeRZ_Z_X R hRZgVc Wc`^ eYV ;`UV) ,2


 
7FF<D;@N 7 7IIE9@7J<kI 7>H<<C<DJ JE 9ECFBO A YRgV cVRU eYV GZVcZd GYRc^RTVfeZTR]d' A_T) ;`ca`cReV ;`UV `W ;`_UfTe R_U =eYZTd %eYV m;`UVn&) A YRgV `SeRZ_VU R_ Z_eVcacVeReZ`_ `W R_j ac`gZdZ`_ RS`fe hYZTY A YRU R bfVdeZ`_) A RXcVV e` RSZUV Sj eYV ac`gZdZ`_d `W eYV ;`UV) 9RdVU `_ ^j cVgZVh' A RT\_`h]VUXV eYRe QQQQQ K` eYV SVde `W ^j \_`h]VUXV' A R^ _`e Z_ gZ`]ReZ`_ `W' `c RhRcV `W R_j gZ`]ReZ`_ Sj `eYVcd `W' R_j ac`gZdZ`_ T`_eRZ_VU Z_ eYV ;`UV6 FI QQQQQ A YRgV ^RUV R Wf]] UZdT]`dfcV `_ eYV cVgVcdV dZUV `W eYZd RT\_`h]VUXV^V_e `W eYV WRTed cVXRcUZ_X R_j a`ddZS]V gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ac`gZdZ`_d dVe W`ceY Z_ eYV ;`UV) A_ RUUZeZ`_' A f_UVcdeR_U eYRe A R^ cVbfZcVU e` cVa`ce R_j dfdaVTeVU `c RTefR] gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV ;`UV' R_U eYRe A ^Rj ^R\V dfTY cVa`ced `_ R Wf]]j R_`_j^`fd SRdZd eYc`fXY eYV ^VTYR_Zd^d UVdTcZSVU Z_ eYZd ;`UV) A f_UVcdeR_U eYRe A R^ cVbfZcVU e` T``aVcReV Wf]]j hZeY eYV T`^aR_j Z_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV Z_gVdeZXReZ`_ `W R_j dfdaVTeVU gZ`]ReZ`_) A f_UVcdeR_U eYRe ^j WRZ]fcV e` T`^a]j hZeY eYV ;`UV `c Zed ac`TVUfcVd ^Rj cVdf]e Z_ UZdTZa]Z_Rcj RTeZ`_' fa e` R_U Z_T]fUZ_X eVc^Z_ReZ`_) 9j5 <ReV5 ER^V %G]VRdV acZ_e&5 <VaRce^V_e*C`TReZ`_5 8(,